A Fermanagh police inspector who
did “favours” for friends, while
operating £12,000 worth of
insurance scams from his office in
Omagh RUC Station was jailed for
two years last Friday.
In all 45-year-old Omagh-based inspector Derek John
Robinson, arrested following a 15 month uncover investigation
known as ‘Operation Cormorant’ between October 1995 and
February 1997, pleaded guilty to a total of 17 charges.
Craigavon Crown court, sitting in Belfast heard that Robinson,
described by his defence QC Charles Adair as a broken man,
used his position as a prosecuting inspector to get his friends
lighter magistrate court sentences.
Jailing him trial judge Mr Justice McLaughlin said he’d admitted
“a proverbial catalogue of offences which would make even a
hardened criminal blush and in the case of a police officer, let
alone one of high rank, constitutes infamous conduct on your
part”.
He added that in the early years the conduct of Robinson,
described as a “high-flyer” within the RUC, rapidly rising through
the ranks to become an inspector within ten years, had been
above reproach.
But that by the early 1990s he had “lost his way” and from 1992
to 1997 allowed his “blatant professional misconduct and
dishonesty, motivated by greed, to become an integral part of
your life”.
The court also heard that from his inspector’s office Robinson
also ran a motor insurance scam. The RUC man, who had a
passion for motoring, would carry out repairs on vehicles and
then claim for them, telling the insurance companies the repairs
had been carried out by authorised dealers.
On other occasions he would clock the mileage of cars which he
bought in England and sold to unsuspecting motorists in the
north.
Robinson’s 33-year-old girlfriend Jocelyn Louise Serplus, an
RUC constable, whose address was also given as Omagh RUC
Station, who wrote him a bogus letter for presentation to a
magistrate four years ago for one of his friends in a driving case,
was freed on 100 hours of community service.
Mr Justice McLaughlin said but for Robinson’s influence over her
she would never have helped in perverting the course of public
justice to which she pleaded guilty.
Her lawyer Brian McCartney said Serplus was “greatly shamed”
for what she had done and now realised it was “wholly wrong
and stupid”.
A 34-year-old Strabane father of two, Martin Carnes, whose
address was given as c/o Melmount Road in the border town,
who earned £,2000 from one of Robinson’s insurance scams
and also helped to ‘clock’ the mileage on a car was freed on a
suspended six month sentence after the judge ruled he wasn’t
“the prime mover” in either offence.
Mr Justice McLaughlin told Robinson that his offences relating to
perverting justice were “particularly serious”, causing as they did
“harm to the prosecution and judicial systems which must be
kept beyond reproach at all times”.
However, he added while Robinson’s crimes represented a
“serious breach of trust, a grave dereliction of duty” it would
appear he was not motivated by greed in this instance, which
was the main factor in his favour.
Mr Justice McLaughlin told Robinson: “You appear to have been
motivated by a misplaced desire to do favours for people, rather
than to gain any direct financial benefit. I accept you were not so
acting to that end”.
But the judge said in his other crimes this was not the case and
told him in those instances “you were engaged quite clearly in
making false insurance claims and car mileage clocking out of
pure greed”. But in mitigation, said the judge, Robinson had
come from a respectable background, and although separated
from his wife, still maintained her and their children. He had
pleaded guilty and has been suspended from the RUC since
1997.
He added Robinson now faced losing his job and with it the
esteem and loyalty of his former colleagues, but given the fact he
was earning £46,000 a year and had gained only £12,000
though his illegal activities, made his crimes “all the more
inexplicable”.
Prosecuting QC Terence Mooney told the court the charges of
conspiracy to pervert public justice, arose out of Robinson using
his position as a police inspector, either to interfere before court
cases, or when he failed to present a number of pertinent facts
to the courts.
In one instance, he added, a driver clocked at speeding at over
100mph, Robinson contacted the officer in charge of the case
and tried to get her to drop the prosecution.
But, said Mr Mooney, the case did come to court, but Robinson
did not present the full facts and even handed in a letter to the
magistrate which appeared to suggest the driver had been on “a
mission of mercy”.
The letter was written by Serplus in his office. Serplus, pleaded
guilt to aiding and abetting Robinson in perverting the course of
public justice. Mr Mooney said there was no evidence to suggest
she would have been involved but for Robinson.
Defence QC Charles Adair, who handed in several medical
reports together with a pre-sentence report from the probation
services, claimed that they indicated the court was dealing with a
“45-year-old broken man”.
Mr Adair said Robinson first joined the RUC in 1975 and made
sergeant in under three years and inspector within another six
making him “really a high-flyer in the service”.
He added that after several postings he was transferred to
Strabane “and perhaps the roots of his depression started
there”, because he was also targeted by the INLA while serving
at the border station and saw colleagues injured and murdered.
He was then moved on to Omagh RUC Station and the offences
began, but they were committed during a time when Robinson
sought the help of police psychiatrists in and around 1995, long
before he was aware of any investigation into his activities.
The lawyer added that once he pleaded guilty late last year
Robinson tendered his resignation to the police authorities, but
that resignation was not accepted.