Extent of apparent 'classic Ponzi' revealed
Published: 6 Sep 2012 13:00
One Irvinestown businessman pumped £116,000 into the County Donegal-based scheme, which offered returns of up to 40 per cent in just six weeks.
In fact it appears to have been a Ponzi, where the returns paid to investors are from their own money, or money paid by subsequent investors, rather than from any actual profit earned.
The full extent of the scheme operated by Frenchman Francois de Dietrich through his company, ETIC Solutions Ltd., has only now been made public.
Following a meeting of creditors in Monaghan at the end of July, PWC (Price Waterhouse Coppers), the official liquidators of ETIC Solutions, has revealed that 576 people invested almost 20 million euro in the scheme.
It also confirmed that it "found no evidence that the company performed any genuine business activity".
"Indications that 'profits', referred to in correspondence from the company and received by investors, were not genuine and were actually the capital other investors had invested," PWC stated.
In other words it appears to have been a classic Ponzi.
De Dietrich has insisted the business was legitimate.
Of the 576 people who invested in ETIC Solutions, only 389 have declared an interest in getting their money back.
PWC does not say how many of the investors were from Fermanagh but one high street bank has revealed that of the 20 of its customers who put money into ETIC Solutions, eight were from Fermanagh.
"And that is only the tip of the iceberg," according to one investigator.
"A lot of greedy businessmen around Fermanagh thought their golden goose had landed and they have lost an awful lot of money," he added.
PWC has spent 18 months trying to track down the missing millions. So far it has seized cash to the value of 7.6 million euro, or just over £6 million.
It estimates that this will result in investors getting an interim payment of 20p for every £1 they invested. They are due to receive the money from early next year.
The 187 investors who have not yet come forward will not get any money back.
De Dietrich enticed people to invest in his business, ETIC Solutions Limited, based at an office in Ballyboffey, with the promise they would make up to 40 per cent profit in the space of six weeks.
Those caught up in the scheme included a PSNI detective, gardai, accountants, solicitors, developers and members of the travelling community.
De Dietrich fled Ireland two years ago, when the authorities froze his accounts and shut down the scheme.
Since then investors have been waiting to get their money back.
Last January the businessman was sentenced to 18 months in jail for contempt at Belfast High Court, after he defied a court order to stop taking new deposits from investors.
When he did not turn up for the hearing a warrant was issued for his arrest.
His appeal against the sentence was dismissed by the Court of Appeal in January.
PWC liquidator Paul Rooney said: "In 2008, 2009, we had the perfect storm of an economic recession and a banking crisis. People were unsure where to put their money.
"Perhaps an opportunity of an investment, and an early investment, was taken and the implications and ramifications of that are now being felt, not just from a financial perspective, but from the human and indeed the families affected," Mr Rooney said.
Not everyone who invested in the scheme lost money - 81 people made a profit.
They cashed in before the scheme collapsed and shared just over £6 million.
Meanwhile, de Dietrich is still a wanted man on both sides of the Border.
The PSNI and gardai both want to question him about the case.
Get more stories from our Roundup section
7 Mar 2014 15:00
Fermanagh Trust @FermanaghTrust Taxes do NOT cover the cost of Children’s Hospice @NIHospice but do fund play parks, business support services, airport hangars, etc WHY?
7 Mar 2014 13:00 • Editorial Department
ROARING engines and squealing tyres may become a thing of the past in Hollyhill link car park after Fermanagh District Council teamed up with the PSNI and Road Service to tackle the problem.
7 Mar 2014 11:50 • Editorial Department
Police are releasing an efit image based on a description of a man they would like to speak to.
7 Mar 2014 11:00 • Lily Dane
Pictured 50 years ago are Mrs. Florence Carrothers, Saloon, Ballinamallard (on right) and Miss Dorrie Foy, of Wheathill, Derrygonelly, who share the Hassard Cup as they were equal in gaining the greatest number of points in the home baking section of the County Show.
7 Mar 2014 10:00 • Rodney Edwards
SINN Fein’s Phil Flanagan (pictured) has described the behaviour of some financial institutions as “disgraceful” after he was charged £168 for four failed direct debit payments by his bank.
7 Mar 2014 09:25
Holders Enniskillen Town Utd will have to overcome Junior Cup semi-finalists Lisnarick if they are to book their place in the quarter-finals of the Impartial Reporter Mulhern Cup.
6 Mar 2014 21:20 • Rodney Edwards
Firefighters are dealing with a blaze in Donagh tonight (Thursday).
6 Mar 2014 21:00 • Julie Kenwell
DIRECTOR of this year’s Enniskillen Drama Festival says he fears for the future of the event on the eve of its opening night.
6 Mar 2014 19:00 • Rodney Edwards
Spake: “There must be a funeral... there are cones out.”
6 Mar 2014 19:00 • Julie Kenwell
MENTION the term domestic abuse and often the stereotype that comes to mind is a struggle between a male and female in their home.
6 Mar 2014 18:00 • Editorial Department
An armed robber been jailed for three-and-a-half years for holding up the Halifax Bank in Enniskillen using a machete.
6 Mar 2014 17:00 • Rodney Edwards
DUP Councillor Bert Johnston cried “I paid the price” during a lively Council debate on Monday night after a Sinn Fein councillor claimed he had been involved in a fracas many years a go in which “somebody got a kick in the ass.”
6 Mar 2014 16:00 • Editorial Department
FERMANAGH District Council has rejected a proposal by one of its councillors who suggested that it helps Erne Rovers acquire a football pitch.
6 Mar 2014 15:30 • Rodney Edwards
AT least three people in Fermanagh regarded as ‘on-the-run’ have received a so-called secret letter from the Northern Ireland Office, it has been claimed.
6 Mar 2014 15:30 • Editorial Department
The on-the-runs (OTR) issue ought to have been relatively straightforward.
6 Mar 2014 15:30 • Rodney Edwards
A prospective UUP Council candidate has defended himself after he called Sinn Fein MLA Gerry Kelly “scum” and a “tramp” on Facebook.
6 Mar 2014 15:05
Enniskillen Olympic triathlete Gavin Noble is to take a step back from ITU Racing this season as he pursues a career with Specialized Bikes, the Enniskillen man taking up the position of Global Sports Marketing Manager for Triathlon for Specialized.
6 Mar 2014 14:00 • Rodney Edwards
TEMPERS flared in the Council Chamber this week over a proposal to erect commemorative signs at commonwealth war graves in Breandrum Cemetery in Enniskillen.
6 Mar 2014 14:00 • Mark Conway
Century TV, for whom former Impartial Reporter journalist Graham Little runs the Northern Ireland operation, will be the host broadcaster for the world famous Giro D’Italia which comes to Northern Ireland in May.