Sadistic abusers 'camouflage' injuries to children, Millie trial told

Published: 26 Nov 2012 19:45

Sadistic child abusers will target areas where the injuries are not apparent, a consultant paediatrician has told the Millie Martin murder trial.

Rachael Martin arriving at court with a friend and (inset) Barry McCarney.

Dr. Joanne Nelson also said that abusers can "camouflage" their activities by inflicting a wound on top of an existing injury.

She was giving evidence as an expert witness at the Dungannon Crown Court trial of Millie's 27-year-old mother, Rachael Martin, and Martin's 33-year-old former lover, Barry "Budgie" McCarney.

Martin, from Main Street, Kesh, denies failing to protect Millie from the unlawful act that caused her death, and wilfully neglecting her in a manner likely to cause her unnecessary suffering.

McCarney, from Woodview Crescent, Trillick, who denies murdering Millie, is also accused of sexually penetrating the infant girl, and with unlawfully and maliciously causing the child grievous bodily harm, and causing her death by an unlawful act.

Martin's defence QC John McCrudden asked Dr. Nelson about a bruise to Millie's right ear.

Dr. Nelson said that if a toddler stumbles and falls against a hard surface it is "entirely possible for a child to sustain an injury of that nature".

She agreed that the injury could have been caused my Millie falling against a chair, adding: "I'm surprised at the extent of the bruising".

Mr. McCrudden asked her if that injury alone could have caused the "large-scale, obvious and widely distributed" bruise observed by witnesses and if someone smacking or hitting the child in that area would "camouflage" the injury.

Dr. Nelson replied: "A second injury, if it was inflicted over the first, could be camouflaged by the first."

She said she had seen this camouflage activity before and, referring to "sadistic abusers" said: "I have seen them target areas that aren't apparent, such as the soles of the feet or under the clothes".

She told the court that was why, when training doctors how to spot abuse, she tells them to take off the child's clothes and examine them "from top to toe".

Earlier the court heard that Millie took her first steps on her first birthday in September 2009, coinciding with McCarney moving in with her mother.

Mr. McCrudden asked Dr. Nelson how prone toddlers were to injury.

Dr. Nelson told the court that toddlers learning to walk "fall and stumble frequently" and "it's very common for toddlers to have bruises".

She explained that a baby's head is relatively big and the head is the heaviest organ in the body so if a child falls or stumbles "it's likely your head will hit something first" and bruising to be found around the forehead and scalp.

The doctor referred to a video, previously shown to the court, of Millie " can see her gait is very slightly wobbly".

Mr. McCrudden asked about the bruise-like mark found on Millie one morning, where it was indicated she might have hit her head on her cot or the wall.

Dr. Nelson said that if the child had been knocked unconscious or was vomiting or had a seizure "these would be markers of deep concern".

The doctor was asked about a second injury, a week or so later, when McCarney called Martin into Millie's bedroom and the child had a "blue lips" and bruising to the forehead.

Dr. Nelson said the lips turning blue can indicate a reduction in oxygen in the blood, where the child has stopped breathing spontaneously or been smothered by bed clothing or a hand been put over their face.

Mr. McCrudden suggested that smothering by clothing or a hand would also "suppress any noise from the child".

"Yes," replied Dr. Nelson.

Turning to the 21 rib fractures suffered by Millie, the doctor told the court "it's very difficult to diagnose rib fractures in children" adding that "it's very rare for a carer who hadn't actually inflicted the injuries themselves to realise a child has rib fractures".

She said rib fractures are "relatively common" in abuse cases and "may not, or likely not be detected clinically".

She added that it was also difficult for a "lay person, or a medical person" to detect the internal injuries of the type suffered by Millie.

Martin's defence case was formally closed today. The lawyers are now preparing their closing speeches.

The case continues.

Jump to first paragraph.

Get more stories from our Roundup section

23 Apr 2014 15:35

Car stolen in "creeper burglary"

A car was stolen during a so-called “creeper burglary” at Raceview Court near the Cornagrade Road in Enniskillen.


23 Apr 2014 13:15

Castle Archdale hosts Dawn Chorus event

LOCAL people are invited to meet at Castle Archdale at 5am on Saturday, May 3, to listen to the birds welcome the new day in fine voice.


23 Apr 2014 11:30

Radio DJ includes Fermanagh stop in marathon challenge for charity

A radio DJ will bring her fundraising marathon challenge to Fermanagh this June in aid of Cancer Research UK.


23 Apr 2014 09:30

Arsonists responsible for 15 gorse fires since beginning of April

Arsonists are being blamed for starting around 15 gorse fires in the Garrison and Belcoo area since the beginning of April.


22 Apr 2014 17:00

Mallards slip into bottom two

Ballinamallard United slipped into the bottom two in the Danske Bank Premiership on goal difference following today's 2-2 draw with Dungannon Swifts at Ferney Park.


22 Apr 2014 15:00 • Editorial Department

Opinion - Kylie Noble - Why I’m excited to vote for the first time

The rites of passage of growing up vary from person to person but throughout my own life events such as turning 13, my first formal, my GCSE and A level results, my 18th birthday (and my first and to date only hangover that followed), getting into university and moving away from home are just a few which I imagine are pretty common landmarks among my generation.

Social: Comments0 comments

22 Apr 2014 15:00

Rucksacks stolen in car break-in

A car was broken into at Navar Forest near Derrygonnelly last night (Monday).


22 Apr 2014 13:00 • Rodney Edwards

Stormont Files: Farm Watch designed to prevent rural crime - O'Neill

FARMERS in Fermanagh are being encouraged by the College of Agriculture, Food and Rural Enterprise (CAFRE) in Enniskillen to take part in the Farm Watch Scheme, an initiative endorsed by Agriculture Minister Michelle O’Neill.


22 Apr 2014 12:00

Lisnaskea home attacked

A house in Lisnaskea has been attacked.


22 Apr 2014 11:00 • Rodney Edwards

Stormont Files: Litter droppers approach MLA to quash £75 fine

A NUMBER of people in Fermanagh have been fined £75 for “dropping a cigarette butt or a sweet paper” on the street, according to UUP MLA Tom Elliott.

Social: Comments0 comments

22 Apr 2014 09:00

Motorist knew insurance shown to police had been cancelled

A 47-year-old factory worker has admitted fraudulently using a certificate of car insurance by showing it to the police, knowing it had been cancelled.


21 Apr 2014 22:30

Man(20) took father's car without consent

A 20-year-old man thought he was being “sensible” when he got behind the wheel of a crashed car to drive it home.


21 Apr 2014 19:00

Jail sentence for driver caught without insurance four times in two weeks

A 30-year-old car dealer caught driving without insurance four times in two weeks despite paying out £3,500 in premiums has been given a jail sentence.


21 Apr 2014 17:30

Number out of work in Fermanagh fell by 2.4 per cent in March

Unemployment in Fermanagh fell by 2.4 per cent last month.


21 Apr 2014 15:00 • Meadhbh Monahan

Steering a safe path of expansion through the downturn

Liam Connolly Road Freight (LCRF) provides groupage services (i.e. from single pallet collections to full double-deck trailer collections) for over 300 customers throughout Ireland and the UK each day.

Social: Comments0 comments

21 Apr 2014 13:00 • Rodney Edwards

Irish President is latest to commend work of Enniskillen church leaders

THE work of Enniskillen’s two main church leaders, the Very Rev. Kenneth Hall and Monsignor Peter O’Reilly, has received a warm acknowledgement from yet another head of state.

Social: Comments0 comments

21 Apr 2014 09:00 • Editorial Department

Not against a community centre but not on ‘our doorstep’

“WE are not against a community centre, we just don’t want it on our doorstep.”

Social: Comments0 comments

20 Apr 2014 19:00

'We want to do it for the supporters' - Davy Black

Clogher Valley coach David Black has vowed to make up for their All Ireland Junior Cup Final defeat by winning the Ulster Towns’ Cup for their supporters when they take on Donaghadee at Ravenhill on Easter Monday.


20 Apr 2014 15:00 • Julie Kenwell

Family ‘sick of thought’ of third round of heart surgery for Alfie

THE family of Bellanaleck toddler, Alfie Keys are nervously looking ahead to this September.

Social: Comments0 comments

20 Apr 2014 13:00 • Editorial Department

Trust identifies ‘extreme risks’ that could kill patients

Extreme risks have been identified by the Western Trust which could “compromise client safety” or even lead to “injury or death of patients or staff”.

Social: Comments0 comments