Barry McCarney guilty of murder, Rachael Martin not guilty
Published: 4 Dec 2012 16:11
The 33-year-old paedophile has also been found guilty of sexually and physically abusing the 15-month-old toddler.
The jury at Dungannon Crown Court found Millie's 28-year-old mother, Rachael Martin "not guilty" of involvement in her daughter's death.
The judge, Mr. Justice Stephens, told McCarney that his "despicable crime is almost beyond understanding" as he passed the mandatory life sentence, and put him on the Sex Offender's Register.
Mr. Justice Stephens also told McCarney that "this jury has clearly understood, and you for your part should understand, you are going to prison for a very long period of time".
McCarney, of Woodview Crescent, Trillick, displayed no emotion at his conviction, which comes just a week shy of the anniversary of Millie's death on December 11, 2009, from massive head injuries.
However, Millie's mother, Rachael, who turned 28 last week, wept uncontrollably in the dock, as she was acquitted of involvement in the death of her 15-month-old toddler. Hugging her sides and swaying backwards and forwards in the dock, she repeated over and over..."thank-you, oh thank- you", before adding "justice has been done for my daughter".
Martin of Main Street, Kesh, who maintained she'd done everything to protect her "angel" was cleared of allowing McCarney to kill her daughter and of wilfully neglecting her during the three months she and him were lovers.
It had taken the jury just under three hours to reach their unanimous verdicts which were greeted with muted cheers and air-punches by family and friends of Martin in the packed public gallery.
Mr. Justice Stephens, while jailing McCarney for life for murder, will hold a tariff hearing in the New Year to determine how long the convicted killer will have to serve before it is considered safe for him to be released back into society.
During the 10-week trial the court heard that in addition to the fatal blow to the back of her head, Millie had suffered a multitude of other injuries, including horrific internal injuries which could have proved just as fatal.
These injuries to her abdomen had been caused by punching or prodding not only in the weeks, but possibly even in the hours before her death.
The child also had 21 cracked ribs. According to specialists seven were old and healing, while a further 14 were less than 10 days old and still fresh. These wounds, it was said, had been caused by grabbing and forcibly squeezing the child's small chest.
There were also multiple bruises, almost from head to toe on her infant body, and an oval, egg-shaped lump on her forehead, which was clearly visible for all to see in the weeks leading to her murder.
Millie had also been subjected to a sexual assault, which it was suggested may have been caused by blunt force trauma, such as a punch to her genital area, as opposed to actual penetration.
Throughout the 35 days of evidence and legal argument, McCarney never once spoke in his own behalf, instead he relied on his defence QC Eilis McDermott to cross-examine witnesses and to make his case that he was the innocent victim of vile circumstance.
By their verdict the jury have rejected Ms McDermott's claims it was his lover, the child's mother, who was really the guilty party, and that the only evidence against McCarney was the word of the investigating police, backed by the prosecution.
The lawyer had claimed that McCarney was an innocent, unaware that Millie's mother: "didn't want the doctor, the social services involved, not because Mr. McCarney was doing these terrible things with her permission, but that she was doing these things herself."
The jury also appears to have refuted Ms McDermott assertion that there was "zero" for them to consider for while the "police say it was him, the prosecution say it was him", there was "not a scrap of forensic evidence" against McCarney, even though "no stone had been left unturned".
Instead the jury accepted the case of prosecution QC Ciaran Murphy who successfully argued that Millie was the victim of "vile, sadistic abuse" and that as a jury, because "Millie's life was short, sad and cruel", they should, "do justice for her".
They must also have accpeted an adverse inference could be taken against McCarney in his refusal to give evidence on his own behalf, in a case which the prosecution claimed had cried "out for explanation .... instead he has chosen silence".
However, the jury, by their verdicts, rejected the prosecution case that Millie's mother was equally guilty for having "turned a blind eye" to McCarney's abuse.
Mr. Murphy had argued that she did not need hindsight to understand what Millie was suffering, all she needed was to "open her eyes and see what was going on in her own house with her own daughter".
The jury thought otherwise, deciding that Martin had done everything a mother could do to protect her baby daughter, unaware, as she herself had said, that she had unwittingly let a "monster" into her home.
They also accepted the assertion of her defence QC John McCrudden that nothing could be further from the truth that Martin had turned from being a loving, caring, devoted mother into a vile, evil murderess.
Get more stories from our Roundup section
20 Apr 2014 13:00 • Editorial Department
Extreme risks have been identified by the Western Trust which could “compromise client safety” or even lead to “injury or death of patients or staff”.
20 Apr 2014 09:00 • Editorial Department
Tempo Primary’s long serving caretaker - whose family has a long connection with the Fermanagh school - was paid a warm tribute at the start of the school’s Easter Holidays.
19 Apr 2014 21:00 • Brian Donaldson
The countdown to the first election for seats on the new Fermanagh and Omagh District Council on May 22 has begun with the first candidates nominating at Enniskillen Townhall this week.
19 Apr 2014 17:10
Ballinamallard took another step closer to safety as they claimed a share of the spoils at home to Ballymena today.
19 Apr 2014 15:00 • Meadhbh Monahan
Founder of Frack Free Sussex and Britain and Ireland Frack Free, Vanessa Vine visited Enniskillen last Saturday to discuss the local anti-fracking campaign.
19 Apr 2014 13:00 • Editorial Department
A boxing champion shied away from a fight with a man over twice his age only to become embroiled in a road rage incident.
19 Apr 2014 11:00 • Editorial Department
The forty-eight former Fivemiletown milk suppliers have been assured that Fivemiletown and Brookeborough Co-operative and Agricultural Dairy Society (the Society) is debt free and that they will “continue to be paid”.
19 Apr 2014 09:00 • Rodney Edwards
ULSTER Unionist MLA Tom Elliott has joined his party colleagues in voting against the Local Government Bill, the legislation that sets out the powers of the new Super Councils. Mr. Elliott spoke of his concern around community planning ahead of the amalgamation which will see 26 Councils merge into 11, including the amalgamation of Fermanagh District Council and Omagh District Council
19 Apr 2014 08:30
Police can confirm that a male motorcyclist has died following a two vehicle road traffic collision on the Belfast Road in Fivemiletown last night, Friday 18 April.
18 Apr 2014 22:00 • Rodney Edwards
A MAJOR survey into the Orange Order in Fermanagh has found that 92.8 per cent of people who took part in the project believe Catholics are “suspicious” of the organisation.
18 Apr 2014 19:00
By 5pm on Saturday April 26 all the decisions will be made in the Danske Bank Premiership and Championship One. The destination of the title will be decided and who is going down or which teams are facing a play off will be known.
18 Apr 2014 17:00 • Rodney Edwards
ENTERPRISE Minister Arlene Foster says she cannot support the view of local political representatives, including her DUP colleague Maurice Morrow, that the Aventas Group in Derrylin must remain exclusively locally owned.
18 Apr 2014 15:00 • Editorial Department
Charlie Lawson @charlie_lawson1 I’m reliably informed that my alter ego and constant companion is to return, so he is. Must contact The Home Secretary to confirm.
18 Apr 2014 13:00 • Editorial Department
“I am not powerless, I will fight this,” declares Stormont Minister Arlene Foster as she reflects on the fall-out over the proposal by the Western Education and Library Board to amalgamate Portora Royal School with Collegiate Grammar School.
18 Apr 2014 11:00 • Lily Dane
This image “Miss Derryclavin” Selected was featured in The Impartial Reporter on April 16, 1964.
18 Apr 2014 08:30
MOURNERS at the funeral of Brookeborough man Kenneth Andrews who died unexpectedly last week were told that the 47-year-old had been fighting a private battle with depression.
17 Apr 2014 18:06 • Rodney Edwards
A would-be politician seeking a seat in the new Fermanagh and Omagh Council for the Ulster Unionist Party has defended himself for a second time following comments he made on Facebook.
17 Apr 2014 17:01
Let me get the amateur sociology out of the way first: ‘Out-group homogeneity’. It describes a bias that any group of people are prone to have.
17 Apr 2014 16:30
The proposed Development Proposal to close both Enniskillen Collegiate School and Portora Royal School and open a new school on a split site, will go before the members of the Western Education and Library Board on May 8 for approval.