A former Fermanagh MP and MLA has warned that any assisted dying legislation that comes into law could be open to abuse.
Lord Elliott of Ballinamallard was speaking after the House of Commons in Westminster voted the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill past its first stage.
The Bill has a number of stages to go through before it is given Royal Assent. If successful, then those medically diagnosed as having six months or less to live will be given the option of being assisted to die.
Campaigners in support of this Bill welcomed last week’s result saying it was the first step in ensuring that terminally ill patients do not have to endure any more suffering than they have to.
However, Lord Elliott fears that while the legislation would be ethically applied at first, he fears that further down the line, it could be open to abuse in order to alleviate financial pressures on the Health Service and struggling families.
“(If it comes into law) it may start off as not too bad with it only being applied to those who have a real need for it,” said Lord Elliott.
“But it has been shown in Canada and other areas that over the years, you’ll all of a sudden find a much more pressurised approach being taken. For example, if a health service is under pressure, people may be pressurised to invoke it.
“I think this could be opened up to abuse a few years down the line. I genuinely do understand why some people wish for this. But I just think that it is spread too far in that it will put enormous pressure on people.
“If you imagine a family that is maybe struggling financially with an elderly parent needing to get care or be moved to a care home that has to be paid for, can you imagine the pressure there would be on that individual?
“They might think to themselves that they’re trying to survive for just another year but under the circumstances, they feel they have to help the family out (under this proposed law).
“So maybe greater access to palliative care could be the way forward? Or even to the lead up to palliative care where people are requiring extra domiciliary care.
“Because someone might decide that their circumstances are a burden on their family and be asking themselves if they should be taking the easy way out.”
Meanwhile, Gavin Walker who is the Chairman of assisted dying activist group, My Death, My Decision NI has welcomed the vote result and has called on local politicians from all parties to actively engage in the debate on assisted dying.
Results of a poll commissioned by My Death, My Decision NI completed by LucidTalk last summer on assisted dying. (Image: My Death, My Decision NI/ LucidTalk) Mr. Walker, who himself has family in west Fermanagh, said: “The debate at Westminster last Friday was an impressively respectful exchange of views which showed our Parliamentary system at its most powerful.
“In light of this vote, the Northern Ireland Assembly must now agree on the mechanism that will allow a full debate here.
“In our poll undertaken with LucidTalk earlier this year, two-thirds of the people in Northern Ireland expressed support for the introduction of assisted dying legislation here.
“It is no longer acceptable that our elected representatives are the only ones throughout the UK not to be actively engaging on this issue.
“In each of the jurisdictions across the UK, the proposed assisted dying legislation varies in detail based on the preferences of the people within that jurisdiction.
“We therefore call on the Executive Office to move with speed to completing the administrative tasks required to convene a Citizens’ Assembly and designate the first Assembly to the issue of voluntary assisted dying.”
Share