Letter reveals business concern over Forum redevelopment

2
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

SIX local businesses have raised serious concerns regarding the cost and community impact of the Lakeland Forum redevelopment project.

A letter, sent by the businesses to Fermanagh and Omagh District Council, communicated "deep concern from the business community and the wider public" about the project.

The Impartial Reporter, which has been seen by The Impartial Reporter, has been signed by Balcas, Belmore Court Hotel, Charlies Bar, Elite Electronics, Encirc and Greentown.

The proposed redevelopment is estimated to cost £52m and will see the Lakeland Forum closed for over two years. 

The matter of the letter was raised by Ulster Unionist Councillor Victor Warrington during Tuesday evening's full Council meeting. 

 "I am aware that a letter was received by the council and yourself, Chair. I am just wondering, can we as councillors have sight of that letter?", he asked as he proposed it be sent to the 40 sitting councillors."

He said: "I find it really bizarre that if a letter like that came in from a group of local businesses, I don’t use this term loosely, but if it wasn’t shared and evidently, it wasn’t shared and I raised it at last month’s Policy and Resources committee. I believe that letter was buried and I don’t know for what reason. I would have thought that letter should have been shared with councillors as soon as it came in."

The Council's Chief Executive, Alison McCullagh addressed the letter during the meeting, she said: “The chair received a letter, it was CC’d to me. It was signed by a number of companies.

"I did respond on the chair's behalf in detail to all the points raised; they related primarily to matters that had been considered."

We believe that certain aspects of the current proposal warrant further consideration," the letter states.

The businesses particularly emphasised their concerns about the Forum’s closure for an estimated two-and-a-half years during redevelopment.

"Enniskillen has already been affected by the closure of the BT call centre and the loss of 300 jobs. Shutting the Forum for such a prolonged period would further harm the local economy, reducing foot traffic and revenues for nearby businesses," the letter continued.

On the issue of community wellbeing, the businesses highlighted the Forum’s crucial role. "The Forum is more than just a leisure centre; it serves as a vital community hub, supporting the mental and physical health of residents. Losing this resource for such an extended time risks significant harm to the wellbeing of our population."

The businesses also expressed concerns about the financial impact, including potential rate increases.

"What will the effect be on ratepayers, and how will this affect the Council’s ability to invest in other areas?" they asked. "Given the already constrained Council budget—evident in the recent cancellation of events like the Hallowe’en fireworks—how will the proposed £54 million project be financed?"

While the businesses acknowledged the importance of the £20 million Levelling Up Fund and expressed support for efforts to retain this funding, they urged that more time be taken to refine the project for long-term benefits.

"We believe that a more thorough approach would yield far greater advantages for the community," the letter noted.

The businesses suggested that the Council explore alternatives to ensure continuity of services and enhance both economic and social outcomes.

"One possible solution is a seamless transition to an alternative site for the new Lakeland Forum, allowing services to continue uninterrupted during redevelopment. This would preserve jobs, maintain service delivery, and protect the Forum’s essential role in the community."

The letter went on to propose that the current Lakeland Forum location could then be repurposed post-relocation, offering a vibrant mix of restaurants, shops, and water-based amenities.

In conclusion, the businesses requested that the Council "pause" its plans for the Forum redevelopment.

"In light of these concerns, we respectfully ask that the Council press the pause button on this project. This will allow for further discussions with businesses and the wider community, the exploration of alternative visions for the site, and a thorough evaluation of the project’s economic, social, and financial implications."

The letter closed with a call to work together. "This letter reflects the deep concerns of the business community and the wider public regarding the proposed plans. We urge the Council to consider the alternatives outlined and collaborate with us to find a solution that benefits everyone in Fermanagh."

Ulster Unionist Councillor Mark Ovens accused the Council of burying the letter during Tuesday evening's meeting. 

Alison McCullagh told the chamber: "We receive hundreds, thousands of pieces of correspondence, the items that come to Council or committee are matters which require a decision. The letter that had been received reiterated points that had been already considered, assessed and discussed at length.

It is quite routine for us to respond to all matters of correspondents, I think a lens is being applied to this, certainly, nothing is buried, and there is absolutely nothing new in it."

There was a heated debate in the chamber, which covered many points that had been raised before.

Sinn Féin Councillor Sheamus Greene compared the discussion to 'Groundhog Day'. He continued: "We see a certain party with smoke and mirrors being against the redevelopment of the Lakeland forum."

He continued: If a certain party is against the leisure facilities being built, be honest enough and come out and say it, just come out and say it and they might get more credit in this chamber if they did."

Alliance Councillor Eddie Roofe added:  "To say the you do support the redevelopment but not in its current form, is nonsense, if you don’t support the current form, it means you do not support the redevelopment of the forum, it is simple as that."

Sinn Féin Councillor Tommy Maguire said:  "I find it almost incredulous that an investment of £50 million plus to a state-of-the-art, forward-looking leisure centre in the town of Enniskillen is something to be negative about."

He noted that some councillors who have served multiple mandates on the Council should be aware of the process as they were present at initial meetings in the Lakeland Forum.

He said: "Already in some of the estimates meeting we have been indicated that the impact is not that severe, it fits within our usual target to keep the rates as low as possible. I really have to say this negative media coverage and now negativity in the chamber is incredulous. Councillors would want to think, about what do they want to leave Enniskillen like in 50 years time.

There were further queries on why the report on the full business case was delayed with the Chief Executive responding: "

 "What is happening is the project managers are doing a line-by-line review of the tender assessment that has been submitted. I think it is 170 pages with all of the component cost elements on  each of those they have to do a value for money and market testing which is required of them by the contract.

"We certainly wish that the report be fully comprehensive because it is such an integral part of full business case because members will expect that due diligence to be done and to be fair to the project managers, they can only form their opinion when they have concluded that process.

"I know through our team, there is literally daily engagement and liaison. It is later than I would liked but there is no point in bringing an incomplete report."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos