The real cost of Fermanagh and Omagh District Council

6
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Fermanagh and Omagh District Council is facing growing scrutiny over decisions it is making spanning planning, financial management, and public services.

Residents across the district are increasingly questioning the Council’s priorities, transparency, and its ability to balance community needs with long-term goals.

In June 2021, the Council granted planning permission for a significant retail development outside Enniskillen. The decision sparked criticism from local retail groups, who warned that it could harm the town centre by drawing trade away from independent businesses. Concerns about increased traffic and the long-term sustainability of the town’s commercial hub were raised, with some questioning whether the economic benefits promised by the Council would outweigh the risks. The Council defended its decision, arguing that the development would stimulate local economic growth, but the issue remains a point of contention for many.

In January 2022, disruption caused by town centre improvement works in Enniskillen added to the growing dissatisfaction. Local business owners reported significant drops in trade, with some estimating losses of up to 40 per cent. Many traders criticised the Council for poor communication and questioned the timing of the works, which coincided with the critical recovery period following the lifting of COVID-19 restrictions. While the Council maintained that the works were essential for the town’s long-term viability, the short-term impact left many feeling unsupported.

A court case in November 2022 further highlighted concerns about the Council’s decision-making processes. During a dispute over the “Green Road” in County Tyrone, a judge criticised the Council for failing to present sufficient evidence to prove that the road had been dedicated as a public right of way. The ruling raised questions about the Council’s ability to effectively manage legal disputes and protect public interests.

Public spending has also been a recurring source of controversy. Between September 2022 and May 2023, the Council faced backlash over £145,000 spent on district welcome signs, which many residents deemed wasteful. Critics argued that the funds could have been better allocated to addressing pressing community needs. In February 2023, the Council proposed replacing windows at its Omagh headquarters at a cost of £400,000. By December, the projected cost had doubled to £800,000, prompting further criticism about financial priorities. The project was eventually put on hold, but it left ratepayers questioning the Council’s approach to managing public funds.

In September 2023, the Council approved a £230,000 initiative to install dual-language road signs across the district. While some residents celebrated the move as a step toward inclusivity and cultural preservation, others criticised the expenditure as excessive. The debate reflected deeper divisions over cultural identity and resource allocation within the district.

A proposal to reinstate Halloween fireworks displays in Enniskillen and Omagh in 2023 was rejected by the Council’s chief executive, Allison McCullagh, citing the lengthy procurement process required. Newly elected UUP councillor Mark Ovens had suggested reviving the events, arguing the £30,000 to £40,000 cost was manageable for the Council. The displays were previously cancelled last year, just days before they were scheduled, due to financial pressures. Despite calls to bring back the tradition, the Council deemed the timeline “not feasible,” leaving some councillors and residents disappointed.

The Council also faced criticism in March 2024 from Unite the Union over its handling of waste collection services. A decision to end the “task and finish” system, which allowed workers to leave once their duties were completed, led to accusations that the Council was scapegoating employees for service disruptions. Unite argued that the Council’s policies were the root cause of the issues, raising concerns about staff morale and management practices.

Ms McCullagh and three other staff members were listed among the top-earning local government employees in Northern Ireland last year.

According to figures released by the TaxPayers’ Alliance, Ms. McCullagh earned £148,393 annually, making her one of 47 council employees across the North whose pay exceeded six figures in the 2022–23 financial year. Her salary was just £19,000 less than that of the then Prime Minister Rishi Sunak, who reportedly earned £167,391 in 2023, and over £20,000 higher than the £123,500 salaries of First Minister Michelle O’Neill and Deputy First Minister Emma Little-Pengelly. Three other senior Council officials were also highlighted for their earnings; Kim McLaughlin, Director of Regeneration and Planning, earned £92,586 annually, John Boyle, Director of Community and Wellbeing, earned £91,028, and John News, Director of Environment and Place, earned £89,464.

It was revealed last year that Fermanagh and Omagh District Council paid a Belfast-based communications firm, owned by a serving SDLP councillor, for advice on managing communications, including the backlash over its decision to provide hot food to councillors.

Despite having its own communications department, the Council used ratepayers’ money to engage MW Advocate in April. The firm was tasked with several areas of “strategic communication,” including advising on how to address queries about the secret vote that approved plates of quiche for councillors.

The company’s co-owner, Carl Whyte, who also served as a councillor on Belfast City Council, found his firm providing advice to another local authority. There was no suggestion of wrongdoing by Councillor Whyte.

Although the Council had described itself as a “fully accountable public body whose decision-making is thorough, open and transparent,” it refused to reveal how much public money had been spent on the private PR firm’s services. Later they would finally reveal they had paid the company more than £9,000.

It was also revealed that Fermanagh and Omagh District Council conducts 26 per cent of its business behind closed doors, prompting concerns about transparency and public trust.

The council lost its complaint against this newspaper last year over reports that councillors held a secret vote to approve “free” meals before meetings.

The Impartial Reporter had revealed that members of Fermanagh and Omagh District Council dined on taxpayer-funded chicken curry, beef stew, and other meals, sparking public outrage. The council filed a complaint with the Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO), alleging the coverage was inaccurate and amounted to harassment.

The dispute focused on four articles published between April and May 2024, including one headlined “The Very Hungry Councillors,” accompanied by a cartoon parody of The Very Hungry Caterpillar. The council argued the articles misrepresented Freedom of Information responses and unfairly portrayed its actions.

IPSO investigated but dismissed all claims, ruling the articles did not breach the Editors’ Code of Practice. The watchdog clarified that the harassment clause applies to individuals, not organisations like councils.

The closure of the Lisbellaw Recycling Centre in October 2024 sparked further outrage. Residents expressed frustration over the lack of communication and viable alternatives, seeing the decision as part of a broader trend of reducing essential services.

A public inquiry into the Dalradian Gold Mine project brought the Council’s spending into sharp focus. Over £700,000 was allocated to opposing the project, including hiring external consultants and a barrister. Critics, including a senior planning official from another council, argued that the expenditure was unnecessary, given the involvement of statutory consultees. The decision led to calls for greater transparency and accountability from the Council.

Mid Ulster District Council quickly rejected a request from Fermanagh and Omagh District Council to contribute funds for hiring consultants to review environmental evidence related to the Dalradian project.

Dr. Chris Boomer, the former Head of Planning at Mid Ulster Council, advised his council’s planning committee against the expenditure, arguing it would not provide value for money.

He highlighted that the required environmental oversight was already in place.

In a memo seen by The Impartial Reporter, Dr. Boomer emphasised that claims suggesting the Dalradian environmental report would not undergo independent auditing were unfounded. He asserted that government departments and agencies were already tasked with managing the process.

Concerns arose in November 2024 when it was revealed that the Chinese Consulate had paid for hotel accommodations for a councillor and the chief executive during an official visit.

Delays to the redevelopment of the Lakeland Forum and uncertainty over staff roles at Fermanagh Lakeland Tourism added to the list of challenges facing the Council in late 2024. Plans to exclude a sauna and steam room from the new leisure facility were met with disappointment, while staff expressed concerns about their futures amidst ongoing restructuring.

Last week it emerged how six prominent local businesses had voiced serious concerns over the £52 million redevelopment of the Forum, citing the potential economic and community impacts of the project.

In a letter to Fermanagh and Omagh District Council, signed by Balcas, Belmore Court Hotel, Charlies Bar, Elite Electronics, Encirc, and Greentown, the businesses highlighted worries about the Forum’s closure for over two years during construction. They warned that the prolonged shutdown could significantly harm Enniskillen’s economy, already reeling from the loss of 300 jobs with the closure of the BT call centre, by reducing foot traffic and revenue for nearby businesses.

As the Council prepares for new projects in 2025, including the proposed state-of-the-art leisure facility, public confidence remains fragile. Residents continue to demand greater accountability and transparency, while the Council faces the challenge of demonstrating that it can effectively serve the district and meet its constituents’ expectations.

The past few years have highlighted significant issues in governance, planning, and communication. For Fermanagh and Omagh District Council, the road ahead will require a renewed commitment to addressing these concerns and rebuilding trust with the community.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos