TB status must be considered when discussing farm sustainability

2
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

IT IS without doubt that herds in Co. Fermanagh and Co. Tyrone are no strangers to the conversation of Bovine Tuberculosis (bTB).

During 2024, approximately 17,500 skin test reactors were removed from herds each month throughout Northern Ireland, in efforts to drive forward the eradication of bTB.

With this in consideration, a cumulative cost over the past 20 years in Northern Ireland from herd breakdowns is approximately £750million.

These costs include slaughter costs, compensation costs and vet labour for testing.

There is an argument that is well known and often spoken, yet nothing is done, which is: what percentage of those skin test reactors were actual reactors during slaughter?

It is not uncommon to know that a good portion of cattle sent for slaughter, following failure of the skin test, do not show as bTB reactors during slaughter.

We have heard and seen the argument of the unjust consideration to intervene with wildlife, either be through vaccines or slaughter, more than once.

However, how often has the topic of the unjust slaughter of a healthy, productive animal, that has failed a skin test, that has followed the same procedure for the past 60 years, been discussed?

When considering Sustainability, I like to break it down into digestible pillars to enable focus on certain areas of interest; for example, Environmental and Financial.

With this, farms can easily determine what is holding them back from achieving their full potential.

This will be easier completed when DAERA Northern Ireland finally begin carrying out Carbon Footprinting on each individual farm business.

During the process, farmers will have to acknowledge and discuss practices which they carry out on-farm, such as the Red Tractor and FQAS processes, with the figures and data collected during discussion being processed through a software system.

This will enable farms to know how much emissions they are emitting as an entire [figure] with the practices, number of livestock and land they work with.

However, it should be noted that it will not acknowledge what emissions are captured and regenerated on-farm.

When a farm experiences a bTB breakdown, practices and number of livestock within their holding can alter dramatically, and with that, bTB status absolutely must be considered when discussing Sustainability and Carbon Footprint.

I believe a farm business should not be held accountable for a below-standard performance on paper, when they have recently had to endure a bTB breakdown or are currently going through a breakdown during the data collection process.

During a bTB breakdown, one of the biggest issues is overstocking. This influences calf rearing and management, as well as herd performance and health.

More than once I have heard the phrase, "I have calves in all corners of the yard" when discussing the consequence of bTB breakdown.

As calf sales cannot be completed, farms are left with surplus calves as well as replacements until a clear test, which could be over a year in some cases.

With that, the workload is nearly doubled, rearing facilities are strained, and costs of milk replacer and meal is enhanced.

With a high volume of surplus calves and high input costs, a farm's sustainability will be below a perceived standard on paper.

However, in the ideal situation with a clear bTb status, these factors would not be present.

Therefore, is it entirely fair that a farm business is criticised by the Carbon Footprint when it is not by choice?

Land and sheds are also stretched to their absolute max, which has a serious influence on herd health, performance and sometimes, welfare.

Yet a farm cannot expand or build a shed to withstand the bTB pressure without DAERA rallying down the yard.

Most farmers in Northern Ireland know how to - and want to - farm cost-effectively, look after their land and livestock, but with the 'rat race' it has become challenging to beat the weather and work within the ever-changing climate, year on year.

There must be another pillar considered when evaluating a farm's sustainability effort and final Carbon Footprint figure.

If DAERA do not take the wildlife intervention discussion further, or seek steps to improve the current, outdated bTB skin test, or even acknowledge that this crisis has a huge influence on sustainability, and proposes an unfavourable carbon footprint, perhaps they should consider the consequences of not doing so on the health and performance of livestock, and the mental and physical health of the farmer, and thus, the economic impact on Northern Ireland.

We must focus on practical, realistic approaches rather than chasing figures on a page if we want any sort of regenerative, sustainable future for this industry.

Megan Morrow, Dairy Sustainability Advisor at Dale Farm.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos