One of the major talking points at Balmoral Show was the proposed new Nutrient Action Programme, launched by DAERA Minister, Andrew Muir, and which is currently out for consultation.
There has been widespread criticism of the proposed new programme, with the Ulster Farmers Union (UFU) saying the proposals could devastate local farms.
“According to DAERA, around 3,500 farms will now be forced to meet strict new phosphorus limits.
“For many, this could mean finding more land for slurry spreading or cutting livestock numbers.
“This is a backdoor attempt to shrink herds and flocks which the UFU says is completely unacceptable” said a UFU spokesperson.
AgriSearch, discussing the document at a Balmoral Show breakfast, felt some of the new proposals were introduced without being backed by science.
In presenting his scientific assessment of the proposed new programme, Dr. Sinclair Mayne (Scientific Adviser to AgriSearch) commented that it was essential that proposed new measures are based on robust science, based on peer-reviewed scientific papers, rather than subjective assessment.
This was the basis for the first Action Programme agreed with the EU Commission in 2007, and subsequent revisions in 2007, 2010, 2014 and 2019.
Dr. Mayne noted that DAERA is proposing to carry forward all of the measures in the 2019 NAP Regulations, and to add a number of new additional measures “based on scientific research”.
However, he noted that a number of the proposed new measures were presented without presenting the appropriate scientific evidence base.
Giving several examples, one he cited was the review of chemical nitrogen fertiliser limits for grassland.
“DAERA are proposing to adopt the AHDB Nutrient Management Guide (RB209) as a basis for chemical fertilizer recommendations, based on ‘completion of trials at AFBI’, but no data are presented by DAERA to support the new proposal.
“RB209 recommendations were evaluated in previous reviews of the NAP and rejected on the basis that the recommendations failed to take account of local grass growing conditions and were impractical for application at farm level.
“Under the new proposals, maximum N fertilizer limits for high-yielding silage swards would be reduced from current levels of 272 to 242kg N/ha/year for non-derogated farms, and to 210kg N/ha/year for derogated farms.
“For high-producing grass swards under grazing, maximum N fertilizer limits would be reduced from 272 to 180kg N/ha/year.
“The practical implication of these lower limits is that less grass will be grown, resulting either in additional land being needed to maintain cow numbers or, in many cases, extra concentrates being fed or cow numbers being reduced.”
Another example is the proposed changes to NAP derogation.
Dr. Mayne continued: “AgriSearch are pleased to note that DAERA plan to retain the derogation limit of up to 250kg N/ha/year for ‘grassland cattle farms’, but are very concerned regarding two proposed amendments to the terms of the derogation.
“Significant effort – including a comprehensive scientific case – was required to secure previous derogations and in the consultation document.
“As noted earlier, DAERA are proposing lower chemical fertilizer limits for derogated farms than non-derogated farms, even though the reason for the derogation is to facilitate higher stocking rates, based on manure N outputs up to 250kg/ha.”
A third example is the additional measures for high-risk areas and sensitive sites.
“AgriSearch are extremely concerned regarding the proposal to introduce ‘new focused NAP measures for high-risk areas and sensitive sites’.
“No details are provided of the measurements to be undertaken or the timescale for assessment,” said Dr. Mayne.
Jason Rankin, Strategy Manager at AgriSearch, presented an initial impact analysis of the NAP Consultation proposals using data from AgriSearch’s Beacon Farm Network, the most efficient farm holdings making great use of grazed grass.
No purchased P fertiliser was included in any of the P Balance calculations.
In addition, the new lower P per cent content of concentrates was also used in these calculations (4.7g/kg dairy concentrate, 4.3g/kg other concentrates).
The analysis shows that it is almost impossible for any herd with a milk yield of above 8,000 litres per cow to achieve a P balance of 8kg/ha.
Furthermore, this analysis is based on 2023, which was a relatively benign year.
Mr. Rankin said that AgriSearch’s initial analysis had also indicated that the P balance targets could also severely impact beef finishing units.
“UFU Deputy President John McLenaghan said, ‘We’re being blamed based on percentage phosphorus figures that aren’t even properly measured – they’re modelled by computers’. “These models are only as good as the data they’re given, and this data, the accuracy of which is a concern, is now being used to hammer our farmers.
“At a previous review in 2005, the EU had suggested individual farm phosphorus balances, but after meaningful discussions accepted that it was not necessary.
“Over the following 20 years Northern Ireland farmers have significantly reduced phosphorus balances and at the same time, increased agricultural production.
“These new proposals from DAERA could have devastating consequences for family farms and the wider agri food economy,” added Mr. Rankin.
The consultation document can be found on the DAERA website, will remain open until 23:59 on June 26.
Share