William Irvine: NAP must work with farmers, not against them

3
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

THE latest consultation on Northern Ireland’s Nutrients Action Programme (NAP) has landed with a heavy thud on kitchen tables across Northern Ireland’s countryside.

Farmers know the importance of protecting our environment, but it’s clear that the current proposals outlined in the NAP consultation document and produced by DAERA, have failed to strike the right balance between improving water quality and sustainable farm businesses.

The UFU accept that DAERA has a legal requirement to review the NAP and consult on that, but what they failed to do is properly engage with all stakeholders in advance of publishing their draconian proposals, many of which are just impossible within the timelines set out by the Department.  

Proposals

The new proposals will impact all farms. However, the severity of their impact will vary, and it is important that rather than listening to speculation and rumour, individual farmers work through how their own business might be affected - UFU staff can assist with this.

In general, we can assume that the phosphorus balances will hit many dairy, pig and poultry farms with some beef farms also caught. These are extremely challenging and for some, just impossible to meet, and the alternative of finding more land or cutting numbers is just not achievable. 

For beef and sheep units and hill farms, the move to require all farms to use Low Emission Slurry Spreading Equipment (LESSE) is a bigger issue. For many this is neither practical nor affordable. 

Mandatory uncultivated 3m buffer strips on arable land also has the potential to reduce the area land to grow crops and output. Changes to chemical nitrogen fertiliser limits could restrict grass growth which makes no sense. 

Additional paperwork, more inspections and new ways of fining farmers will add to the administrative burden which is already suffocating many farmers. Also, worryingly, is the potential to increase the rules and regulations even further in unspecified ‘focus areas’. 

All in all, there are around 30 changes proposed. Almost all of which in their current format are unacceptable to the Ulster Farmers’ Union and the wider agri-food sector.

Balanced needed

What’s missing is balance. Environmental rules should be robust, but they must also be realistic, practical and backed up by relevant science and timelines that work for farmers. Otherwise, we risk alienating the very people needed to make these policies work.

However, these are only proposals. The UFU and the agri-food sector have united to raise the genuine concerns around this flawed consultation.

We have jointly instructed solicitors to issue a letter to DAERA Minister Andrew Muir, calling for the immediate withdrawal of the public consultation on the proposed Nutrient Action Programme and outlining several serious procedural flaws with the consultation exercise.

We hope that the Minister will see sense, withdraw the consultation and get round the table with all stakeholders including farmers and environmentalists, to work together to develop a new NAP that works for farmers and the environment.

If Northern Ireland wants lasting improvements in water quality, it must work with its farmers, not against them.

William Irvine is the current president of the Ulster Farmers' Union (UFU)

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos