A permanent change to EGS at SWAH will be consulted on

File photo of the South West Acute Hospital. Photo: Ronan McGrade.
File photo of the South West Acute Hospital. Photo: Ronan McGrade.
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The Western Health & Social Care Trust (Western Trust) Board has unanimously backed a proposal to hold a public consultation on a permanent change to emergency general surgery (EGS) at the South West Acute Hospital (SWAH).

The proposal entails holding a number of public meetings, with a subsequent report on its findings to be presented to the Western Trust Board this Winter.

First addressing the gathering this morning at Western Trust headquarters about the suspension of EGS at the SWAH – which were first withdrawn in December, 2022 – Western Trust Chief Executive NeilGuckian said: “As a Trust, we recognise the strength of feeling that this change has brought about.

“We now have over two and a half years of working under these pathways.”

Continuing, he said “no patient had come to harm as a result of our change”, and added: “I cannot overstate how important patient outcomes must be.

“I can confirm that the SWAH remains a thriving acute hospital, with the highest patient numbers on record ... I also want to pay tribute to all our staff at the SWAH for their commitment shown through this period.”

Addressing the proposal, Mr. Guckian continued: “Today, we are proposing to consult on a permanent change [to EGS at the SWAH]. I ask everyone to keep an open mind during this consultation.”

Dr. Brendan Lavery, Medical Director, was next to address the Board. Commenting on data collated since the suspension of EGS, he said: “We have over two years of patient data; we have no clinically adverse outcomes [for patients].”

Dr. Lavery continued: “There’s no evidence of an increase in in-hospital mortality following the change.

“We’ve been challenged to show that the change has not affected patient care. Complication rates in general surgery ... show a decrease in surgical complications [at the SWAH].

“Our readmission rate has fallen 10.1 per cent with this change.”

Mark Gillespie, Director of Surgery, Paediatrics and Women’s Health, then spoke, telling the meeting: “We believe the [patient and surgery] pathways are safe, and the data shows the pathways are safe.

“We’ve done extensive work in clinical audit; we’re also very focused on the patients who stay longer periods in wards.

“We’ve also looked at the patients who transfer from the SWAH, and looked at more capacity in Altnagelvin.

“It’s also clear that where a patient can repatriate to the SWAH, they must do so at the earliest possible opportunity – we’re very focused on that.”

Citing available data on patients’ outlook since the suspension of EGS, Mr. Gillespie said: “77 per cent of patients related their overall experience as good or excellent at the SWAH”, but also highlighted patient concerns over long waits at the Emergency Department, or for follow-up appointments.

Turning to the proposal itself, Teresa Molloy, Director of Planning, Performance & Corporate Services, then told the meeting: “We’re very fortunate to have had quite a long period of time when the temporary change has been in place, because it has enabled a considerable period of engagement.

“We’ve been able to put in place a lot of structured engagement. We engage regularly with the Council, we have established an all-party group in the area which meet regularly, and we have a service user group.”

She continued: “We have assessed the requirement and need for a public consultation [on a permanent change to EGS at the SWAH].

“We would intend to launch the consultation on July 8. We would also proactively issue the consultation to a formal Consultee list.

“We will hold consultation events – two face-to-face events, one in Fermanagh, one in Derry, one virtual.

“We would have approximately six targeted consultation events, and we would intend to bring our consultation report brought before the Trust Board in the Winter of 2025.

“Depending on the view of the Trust Board, it would then be published. Enactment would entail Ministerial approvement.”

Following this, the Western Trust Board invited discussion and questions, with Non-Executive Director, Dr. Aideen McGinley OBE, highlighting a number of concerns.

Dr. McGinley said: “This [change to EGS at the SWAH] has been a very difficult process for the people of Fermanagh and Omagh, but also the Trust staff.

“This needs to be a meaningful, transparent consultancy. This [suspension of EGS] has been very traumatic; people feel an acute sense of loss.”

Speaking on the consultancy process, she continued: “What are they really being asked? We need to state our ambition.

“We can say quite clearly it’s about maximising the hospital, stabilising the workforce, improving the pathways and ambulance services.

“This is an iterative process. This is a fundamental change for everybody, and we all share that desire for safe and effective EGS, for all the patients, and an equity of access for surgery.”

In response, Mr. Guckian said: “If you rush a vision, you don’t get the right result. I would absolutely agree that this is a fundamental change, and it will make a significant change to individuals and communities.

“Myself and my team are wholeheartedly supportive of the SWAH.

“I can assure you, everyone in this room has put their shoulder to the wheel to ensure that the SWAH has a vibrant future.

“Yes, that future will be slightly different if this proposal is accepted – but it will be a vibrant future.”

Concluding, the proposal to hold a public consultation on a permanent change to emergency general surgery was then proposed, and seconded.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos