Consider the following: “Justice must not only be done but must be seen to be done.”
Most readers will be familiar with the phrase. It isn’t an old proverb, nor is it just a modern-day social media ‘meme’.
It is a legal ruling from a United Kingdom court case involving a motorcycle accident in 1924.
I knew that much because the late professor Kevin Boyle told me so a long time ago when I used the phrase in his company.
The information was shared lightly and absorbed in the same spirit.
Those were the days before Google made it easy to find out more, or to check out if there was a word of truth in what you had just heard.
At the time, I just took his word for that bit of interesting detail, and stored it somewhere in my brain.
The phrase and the professor came to mind over recent weeks as I read the concerns, and reactions to them, about former senior police officers holding senior positions within the new Legacy Body and the Police Ombudsman’s Office
I did some internet research not because I belatedly doubted an old friend, but because it is now so much easier to find out more.
I felt the need to be sure of my ground, given that such an eminent lawyer as Sir Declan Morgan KC seems to discount the notion as carrying no real weight in relation to the Legacy Body.
I found a fascinating article on the subject published in 2020; the author is Arvind Datar, a Senior Counsel practicing at the Supreme Court of India at the time.
So, you can discount ‘fake news’ as not applicable.
The issue being determined was the presence of a deputy clerk, who had a connection to the case before the court, being in the consultation room when the case was being discussed, and whether his presence potentially influenced the decision.
The author summarises the ruling as follows:
“After setting out the facts, he accepted that the presence of the deputy clerk did not influence their decisions and that he did not participate in their deliberations ... He [ the judge] went on to observe that the question was not whether the presence of the deputy clerk had influenced the decision or whether his firm, being involved in the civil case, had any role to play in the conviction.
“Lord Hewart went on to observe that what was important was not what was done, but what might appear to have been done ... Despite accepting these facts and the fact that the conviction was not influenced by the presence of the deputy clerk, Lord Hewart quashed the conviction.”
The article then quotes the judge’s own words, as recorded in the written judgement. They are worth repeating.
“It is not merely of some importance but is of fundamental importance that justice should not only be done but should manifestly and undoubtedly be seen to be done ... Nothing is to be done which creates even a suspicion that there has been an improper interference with the course of justice.”
Amnesty International, Nuala O’Loane and others are defending this cornerstone of administrative law when they challenge the presence of Peter Sheridan in the Troubles legacy body, and Hugh Hume’s Chief Executive Officer appointment in the Ombudsman’ Office.
The issue is not about these and other appointments as individuals – rather, it is about the cornerstone of administrative law being upheld without fear or favour, and nothing being seen to be done which creates even a suspicion that there has been an improper interference with the course of justice.
Mr. Sheridan, a Fermanagh man ‘born and reared’, was one of few Catholics to join the ranks of the Royal Ulster Constabulary in the mid-1970s.
He later rose to the position of Assistant Chief Constable within the PSNI in 2006 with responsibility for most of the criminal investigation outside the Greater Belfast area.
What I or anybody else might think of the police or Mr. Sheridan is irrelevant.
It is not his integrity that is the issue, nor his organisational or intellectual ability in this role.
It is not that he might or might not have the integrity, wit, or the recall to absent himself from a specific matter in which he may have been personally and specifically engaged.
The existence of the Legacy body is itself a deviation from the course of justice, and opposed by victims’ families, and every political party on the island.
The suspicion is already rife at every level of civil society in Northern Ireland that its purpose is to interfere with the course of justice to protect the State, and ‘National Security’, by protecting from justice, police officers, soldiers and paid agents of the State who were responsible for the deaths that created victims’ families on both sides of the conflict.
That suspicion is increased by a key role in that body being held by anyone who held a senior role within policing, or indeed, the court system or PPS in Northern Ireland over the period of what is now exposed as a very dirty war of attrition.
Sir Declan Morgan, who shouldn’t be in his position either, was a practicing barrister and judge over that period.
The same goes for Hugh Hume, also a former RUC/PSNI senior officer, and senior officer with An Garda Síochana.
The families of the Omagh bombing will have no access to the closed sessions of the Public Inquiry into the Omagh bombing for ‘national security reasons’.
The bereaved, the Truth and Justice proponents, are again subservient to that catch-all phrase under which the whole truth has been buried.
‘National Security’ included protecting agents of the state, and whether written or unwritten, it was part of the job description of all police officers. That is the problem.
Justice cannot be seen to be done if those running the investigations into the past were part of the very justice system that failed to protect the law from being corrupted for ‘National Security’ reasons, and the people from the consequences of corrupted law.
Share