A Premier League station for an Intermediate League service?

Belfast's impressive Grand Central Station is the largest integrated bus and rail hub on the island of Ireland <i>(Image: Google Maps)</i>
Belfast's impressive Grand Central Station is the largest integrated bus and rail hub on the island of Ireland (Image: Google Maps)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Transport is one of those things that has created a very different divide in the divided land we live in.

Usually, it’s our politics that separate us, but when it comes to transport, there’s very much an urban and rural divide.

In Belfast, the buses glide in and out of a shiny new glass mountain in the middle of the city.

But as you head towards our real mountain country in Fermanagh, we’re lucky they’ve even given us a transport hub in our biggest town, Enniskillen.

The buses don’t always run when you need them, and getting to smaller towns off the beaten track can still feel like an endurance test rather than a day trip.

In the last article I wrote, I said I’d be going to watch Fivemiletown United play Drumaness Mills.

That was the plan, anyway.

Fivemiletown play their football at the Valley – a name shared with Charlton Athletic, my local team in London.

But when I looked into bus timetables, the trek to Drumaness would have been as easy as climbing Cuilcagh Boardwalk Trail in bare feet in the dark in the middle of winter.

It’s a mission to get anywhere that’s not a main road to or from the east.

And yet, when you go to Belfast, the contrast couldn’t be sharper.

There, gleaming in the city centre, stands Grand Central Station – a £340million glass-and-steel temple to transport.

It’s the largest integrated bus and rail hub on the island of Ireland, and it certainly looks the part.

The only problem is, it’s almost empty.

When it was first announced, the cost was estimated at around £200million. By the time the doors opened, that figure had ballooned to £340million.

For that, you get 26 bus stands, eight rail platforms, and enough floor space to host a five-a-side football tournament for every Irish League club playing all at once.

What you don’t get is the sense that it’s being used to capacity.

I wandered through it recently and was struck by how quiet it felt. It’s as if someone built a Premier League stadium for a club that competes in the Mid-Ulster Intermediate League.

The scale is staggering, but the demand simply isn’t there.

Near where I live, when in London, there’s a place called North Greenwich. It’s got a constant stream of double-decker buses looping through the day and night – an almost 24-hour service.

Yet it’s a very small station, always packed, always moving.

At Grand Central, by contrast, you could count the departures on one hand. It’s not that Belfast doesn’t need better transport. Of course it does, but the scale feels out of sync with reality.

For all the talk of “integrated transport”, there are still so few routes.

You can get to Bangor, Larne or Holywood very quickly by train – but try getting to some of the southern parts of County Down, or across to Enniskillen or Omagh, and you’re lucky if there’s a bus every two hours.

Derry is the only western destination with a train line at all. West of the Bann, it’s buses or bust.

To be impartial, though, for many in Belfast, Grand Central is a source of pride. It’s the city’s biggest new civic project in years and is seen by some as the first step towards improving provision across the whole region.

But perhaps they should have started with the foundations. Grand Central isn’t even particularly easy to get to, compared with the old Europa Bus Centre.

In its present form, it still resembles a building site – impressive, yes, but half-finished, half-empty, and oddly hard to reach.

There was nothing particularly wrong with the old Great Victoria Street Station, or the Europa Bus Centre. They were a bit tired, a bit cramped, but they worked. People could get where they needed to go.

Now, Grand Central feels more like a property developer’s dream than a commuter’s. It’s surrounded by pubs, coffee chains and talk of great open spaces, but step outside and the old problems remain.

Patchy rural services, long waits and connections that make even a short trip a logistical puzzle.

So why does Belfast need the largest transport hub on the island? Would the money not have been better spent on upgrading smaller bus stations in places like Armagh, Dungannon or Enniskillen? Or even just on running more buses?

The current set-up feels a lot like putting the cart before the horse. And that’s really the heart of it.

Grand Central Station is a statement project, a kind of architectural flex of the muscles. Beautiful, yes. And it even has a trendy BrewDog bar for craft beer and chicken wings.

But it’s built for a future that hasn’t arrived yet.

Some say it’s “future-proofing” Northern Ireland’s transport network, preparing for population growth, tourism, even a potential all-island system in the event of Irish unity.

But you can’t eat the future or fix hospital waiting lists with it.

In a place where you can’t get a Sunday bus to many towns, or any bus any day after dark, £340million on a single transport hub feels hard to justify.

When you stand inside Grand Central, it’s hard not to be impressed. It’s clean, it’s spacious, and it looks like the kind of place you’d want to travel from.

But when you step outside and realise how few journeys it connects, compared to other parts of these islands, it starts to feel less like progress and more like a mirage.

For now, it’s a monument to potential – a Premier League stadium for a League One service.

And while Belfast’s new station gleams like a self-awarded trophy, parts of the country are left waiting at the bus stop, wondering if the next one’s coming at all.

Thank God, though that we have great bus drivers. Whatever team we support, the blue and white of Ulsterbus has always been one that we can get behind.

It’s not their fault that some people in white collars have decided to have a vanity project.

Maybe, like Liverpool’s summer spree, the money could have been better spent. Time will tell, though.

Maybe the urban argument will win through, and it’ll be the best thing since Ormo Bread.

Sometimes it would be nice to be proven wrong.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos