Some places have gone quiet. The corncrake’s long gone from fields where it once called out all summer, and many neighbours have commented this year that there were fewer swallows than usual.
But step onto a well-kept family farm and it’s a different story – hedges alive with wrens, bees working the flowers, and the sound of life all around.
That contrast, not a carbon spreadsheet, tells you more about whether farming is truly sustainable.
While arguments continue over climate targets, carbon budgets, and who’s to blame for water quality, the real story is right there in front of us.
The loss – or return – of birds, insects, and wildflowers says more about the health of our land than any set of figures ever could.
The language of the environment has become complicated. Audits and footprinting have their place, but they’re far removed from the daily rhythm of stock, weather, and bills.
What matters is simple: can a swallow still find mud to build a nest? Do bees still hum along the hedges come June?
None of us have it perfect. Every farm could do better – and most farmers would, if the right support and guidance were there.
What we need isn’t more noise or blame, but trust, practical advice, and schemes that fit how real farms work.
Most farmers work within the limits of the land. We’re not chasing maximum output at any cost; we’re trying to keep the ground alive and productive.
Hedges that shelter birds, fields that hold water in the right places, and a mix of habitats that support wildlife – those things matter. They tell us the system still works.
What’s frustrating is that debates about farming often focus only on the extremes – the industrial image on one side, and outright opposition on the other.
There’s a broad middle ground that rarely gets heard: farmers who believe food and nature belong together, and prove it quietly every day.
If the Government insists on measuring sustainability, at least start with biodiversity – it’s the one thing that shows whether life is returning to the land.
The song of a yellowhammer, the hum of pollinators, a clean drain with sticklebacks darting –those are the real signs of progress.
We can tick every climate box and still lose our living world if we ignore that. But if life returns to the land, carbon and water quality will follow. It’s common sense, not ideology.
So maybe it’s time to stop letting the noisiest few speak for the many. Let’s build policy around the quiet majority who care about the whole picture – stock, soil, and songbirds alike.
We don’t need another metric; we just need to look and listen.
The land is already telling us how we’re doing. Maybe it’s time we started listening better.
Peter Gallagher is High Nature Value Farm Advisor at Ulster Wildlife.
Share