ICO orders PSNI to reveal handling of Jonathan Creswell case

Jonathan Creswell.
Jonathan Creswell.
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) has ordered PSNI to answer another previously refused enquiry into the handling of Jonathan Creswell.

It is the second time intervention has been required and comes amid concerns that PSNI may have misled the ICO regarding the reasons another Freedom of Information (FOI) request was refused.

For almost a year, PSNI avoided answering a straightforward enquiry about whether An Garda Síochána was contacted in relation to Creswell after he fled to Donegal while wanted for exposure in 2016.

The ICO upheld PSNI’s rationale after being incorrectly informed that locating the information would exceed the maximum 18 hours permitted for FOIs.

By that time, however, it had been established through other means that Gardaí were never contacted. Rather than admit this, PSNI deemed the request too expensive to answer.

The information was located in slightly over five minutes.

The response was provided by a member of civilian staff, but it would still have required sign-off by a senior officer.

Mukesh Sharma, Chair of the Policing Board, has written to the Chief Constable, and a complaint has been lodged. Both have been confirmed as received.

Creswell was charged with murdering showjumper Katie Simpson in August 2020. He had claimed to have found her hanging, but there were striking similarities to attacks on his previous partner, Abi Lyle.

Bizarrely, these convictions had disappeared from PSNI systems.

Creswell took his own life 24 hours into his trial for Katie’s murder.

The exposure victim and her partner, referred to as Sarah and Ian for the purposes of this report, had worked briefly with Creswell in County Antrim.

Sarah described him as “boasting of being jailed over Abi, saying his only mistake was ‘not finishing the bitch off’,” adding, “I warned he was dangerous. I wasn’t believed.”

After Creswell exposed himself to Sarah, Ian confronted him, recording the interaction on his phone.

Enraged, Creswell threatened to “snap his neck and break his back” while shouting that Ian’s “c**t girlfriend will get what’s coming”.

With the workplace so toxic, the couple left and contacted police in January 2016, but Creswell was never traced.

Following the end of his trial last year, Sarah complained to the Police Ombudsman. This was rejected as PSNI insisted extensive efforts had been made to locate Creswell and that he was believed to be in Donegal.

The complaint was reopened when evidence contradicting PSNI’s position was presented to the Ombudsman.

Multiple FOIs thereafter were deemed too expensive, and with upfront payment declined, it was clear efforts were being made to shield uncomfortable facts.

However, the rejected enquiries about Garda contact undermined PSNI’s credibility.

Last week, the ICO ordered disclosure of another previously blocked enquiry—specifically, when the Wanted-for-Arrest alert in Sarah’s case was stood down.

Initially, the ICO again supported PSNI, but following further exchanges, the response confirmed Creswell was wanted for interview from February to August 2016, then upgraded to Wanted-for-Arrest from October 2016 until October 2017.

Separately, PSNI confirmed that Wanted Alerts remain live for as long as necessary and can be removed by any officer linked to the investigation.

Given Creswell’s previous record, his absconding while wanted for sexual and violence allegations, and a warning of dangerousness, PSNI was asked to clarify the rank of the officer who stood down the alert and the rationale. There was no answer at the time of publication.

Almost a year ago, PSNI were also compelled to answer FOIs, including the date a forensic post-mortem was requested following Katie’s death.

After initially refusing, the information was provided. A follow-up enquiry then sought the rank of the officer who originally blocked disclosure.

This too was refused but successfully challenged, with PSNI confirming the officer was a Detective Chief Inspector.

The PSNI, ICO and Policing Board have been asked to review all rejected FOIs in this matter—currently 17—to establish whether the refusals were genuine.

At the time of publication, none of these bodies had responded.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos