Trust ‘dismayed’ by Council criticism over SWAH surgery

2
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The Chief Executive and Board of the Western Health and Social Care Trust claim to be “dismayed” by comments made during a meeting of Fermanagh and Omagh District Council, but stopped short of fully responding to enquiries put to them regarding full compliance with the Nolan Principles of Public Life.

Members were discussing the fallout from the Department of Health Committee meeting at South West Acute Hospital (SWAH) and the disclosure that a decision has already been taken against the return of emergency general surgery (EGS).

Chairman Counillor Barry McElduff stated: “This is new information and something we want to look at. There is also a concerning level of disengagement by the Trust, and the Chief Executive (Neil Guckian) hasn’t met with this council for some considerable time. We want to establish exactly what is going on.”

Councillor Adam Gannon, SDLP, said: “The public are asking questions about the Trust and their intentions. Is it incompetence? Is it maliciousness? What are their actions here? They really need to be interrogated because, in effect, the whole consultation was a sham. The decision was made. They lied to every single member of the public, every single member of this chamber, and every elected representative. That is absolutely shocking.”

Ulster Unionist Councillor Victor Warrington remarked: “The Western Trust’s response to us as a body is very disturbing. The Chief Executive has not met with the Health and Social Care Group for over two years, and that in itself is very unsatisfactory. Plus, some of the comments he made last week after the visit to SWAH, such as ‘small beer’, are very, very unsettling. It’s obvious the Trust have their mind made up on the way we are going.”

Following the meeting, the Western Trust was asked to confirm if the Chief Executive and Board are fully adherent to all aspects of the Nolan Principles, in particular honesty, which was seriously questioned by several councillors, including one who stated: “They (the Trust) lied.”

In response to the query, a spokesperson said: “The Trust is dismayed by some of the commentary at the council meeting and will take some time to reflect before making any further comment.”

Meanwhile, the Department of Health was asked a series of questions around the decision not to resume EGS, including when it was made aware of this and what departmental action is being considered.

In addition, the Department was asked to explain why two consultations were launched — albeit one was ended early on Ministerial direction — involving expenditure and resources which appeared unnecessary other than for policy adherence, described in council as “a sham exercise”.

Finally, the Department was asked whether the Minister for Health, Mike Nesbitt, retains full confidence in the Western Trust Chief Executive and Board.

This was also not fully addressed; however, there was some indication of direction, with a spokesperson stating: “The Review of General Surgery NI sets out evidence-based standards for EGS and hospitals delivering EGS must meet these standards. It is for the Western Trust to determine how it will configure its general surgical service to meet these standards on a safe and sustainable basis that meets the needs of its population. In considering the future model for general surgery across the Trust, it must follow the Guidance on the Change and Withdrawal of Services.”

The statement concluded: “Any decision on a permanent change to the delivery of EGS at SWAH will require approval from the Department of Health.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos