SOAS challenge legality of SWAH emergency surgery removal

SOAS and the Western Trust both spoke to the Health Committee <i>(Image: John McVitty)</i>
SOAS and the Western Trust both spoke to the Health Committee (Image: John McVitty)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Save Our Acute Services (SOAS) is to challenge the Western Trust’s decision to suspend Emergency General Surgery at South West Acute Hospital (SWAH).

Solicitors acting on behalf of the campaign group submitted the legal challenge with comments made by senior executives from the Trust in November as grounds.

The challenge is focussing on admissions made by chairman of the Trust Dr. Tom Frawley and retiring Chief Executive Neil Guckian when they spoke to the Stormont Health Committee at SWAH in late November.

Conor Sally, a solicitor acting for SOAS, served a pre-action protocol on the Western Health and Social Care Trust today.

During the meeting in early December, Mr. Guckian replied to Philip McGuigan MLA’s question on the service returning and said: "It would be a new service. It is a fundamentally different service."

Dr. Frawley added: “There is an inevitability this won’t be back, because once you have stopped it, you cannot meet the new standards.”

This was branded a sham by SOAS and they are now focussing on these admissions that there was never any prospect of the surgical service returning to SWAH.

SOAS say it contradicts assurances made during public consultation and Health Minister Mike Nesbitt was forced to clarify to confirm that the decision to remove Emergency General Surgery remains temporary and no decision for permanent withdrawal can be made without his approval.

Spokesperson for SOAS, Donal O'Cofaigh, said: “Following a review by our solicitors of the comments made by senior Western Trust executives before the Stormont Health Committee, they have now advised that a basis existed to issue a pre-action protocol letter. This was sent by our solicitors on behalf of our campaign - and our community - this afternoon.

"The letter gives the Western Trust 21 days to respond. The pre-action protocol is to be considered as immediately preceding an application for a judicial review seeking an order to quash all those WHSCT decisions in particular those which deprive our community of access to acute emergency surgical services.”

The Department of Health, Fermanagh and Omagh District Council, the Regulatory & Quality Improvement Authority, the Public Health Agency and the Patient Client Council were named as interested/notice parties.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos