Fermanagh and Omagh District Council has voted to defer a decision on taking up an invitation to visit China in April.
This followed a close vote to decline the trip completely, which was very narrowly defeated.
Chief Executive Alison McCullagh told councillors: “A similar invitation has issued to five councils and is currently under consideration.
“The Consul’s preference is for the visit to be towards the end of April for six nights; three in Beijing and three in Huangshi.
“The itinerary is expected to involve exchanges with counterparts in trade, education, culture and tourism.”
She said: “The Consul will cover for six people, whether councillors or officers, but would hope for some councillors.
“The last trip was part of our friendship arrangements with Huangshi and Invest NI identified a number of local companies doing business there.
“Former Councillor [Howard] Thornton visited while Chair in 2018 under the auspices of the Northern Ireland Bureau.
“The visit last October [led by the Chair, Councillor Barry McElduff] and this trip would be further development from that.”
Ms. McCullagh added: “It would be very unusual to receive or accept an offer of this extent in terms of financial support.
“I recommend that if we chose to accept, the Council should fund itself.”
Ulster Unionist Councillor Mark Ovens said: “I see no foundation whatsoever to take up that invitation.
“Instead of free trips, this council should focus on issues that matter most to ratepayers, such as emptying bins and keeping parks clean.
“These are what people elect us to do, not to go on trips, whether they are paid for or whether we pay for ourselves.
“We are within days if taking a decision on whether to increase rates, which it’s likely they will.
“This council took up an offer to China late last year, costing ratepayers £5,500, taken from the pockets of local homes and businesses, still to negligible benefit.
“We need to get a grip. I really struggle to see what this could deliver for local people. They expect much, much better.”
He proposed responding to the invitation by saying: “Thank you but we have other priorities at the moment.”
Seconding, party colleague, Councillor Victor Warrington, said: “Even though the trip would be paid for, the general public don’t look into the smaller details. They look at fundamental issues.”
However, Councillor Sheamus Greene, Sinn Féin, responded: “It’s hard to know what position the UUP will take on any given night.
“It’s only a few years from [when] Councillor Thornton led a delegation to China, and I didn’t hear one UUP member speak against it. Now they are criticising.
“If we are going to go down the line, we have to look at all funded trips, including those Unionist parties go on annually.
“I’ve never heard such hypocrisy.”
Councillor Warrington enquired what was meant by the Unionist trips, to which Councillor Greene replied: “They are bound to know themselves. I don’t know why they area asking me, but the Council fund them.”
Party colleague Councillor Debbie Coyle made an alternative proposal that: “We leave the decision for this month, because there has been some feedback of benefits locally.
“But I don’t think anyone’s bin was missed in October when the Chair visited China.”
Seconding, Sinn Féin Councillor Thomas O’Reilly stressed: “I have every confidence in the service delivery of this council to take care of issues which affect daily lives, but I also have a long memory of waiting to see what bigger powers, who led delegations for inward investment, brought to Fermanagh and Omagh.
“Improving the lives of our citizens is part of what we are elected to do.
“To be looking at this one-dimensionally does a disservice, and we have an opportunity to deliver tangible benefits.
“It’s right and proper that we have these links, and if they work, we maximise; if they don’t, we look elsewhere.”
Councillor Robert Irvine, Ulster Unionist, noted: “We are trying to say that we already had one trip to China on a cultural twinning basis.
“This seems to be a slightly different thrust. The gathering of inward investment is for Invest NI, and unfortunately, they have proved very ineffective in our area.
“We should be pushing them to act better. It’s their raison d’être, not ours.”
Alliance Councillor Stephen Donnelly said: “There are three questions for international engagement – objective, value for money and is it ethical?
“It’s problematic if this trip was entirely funded by China, and if were to go, it could only be if we fund ourselves.
“However, I think it would be irresponsible, and I’m unsure if there is a strong argument for us returning so soon.”
Councillor Adam Gannon, SDLP, referred to China’s “questionable human rights record”.
He continued: “We need to be cautious and explore what this relationship is about.
“That’s not to say we shouldn’t engage, but it’s just so soon to the last trip. It wouldn’t be correct to take up the offer at this time.”
With division evident, Councillor Ovens’ proposal went to a vote, which was narrowly defeated 19 – 15.
Councillor Coyle’s proposal also went to a vote, which passed 19 – 12, with two abstentions.
Share