Paul Breen: Will Irish Unity happen? ChatGPT believes it will...

3
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Lately in the media, in education and other industries, there has been a real upsurge in usage of Generative AI for writing. Most probably, Chat GPT is the main driver of all this. It’s very easy to spot usage in some cases, and much harder in others.

The easiest way to work out usage is to look at a writer’s earlier work, or to compare their writing voice with their spoken voice. If somebody turns super-articulate overnight, writing in a brand new style, then there’s something suspicious going on.

But people are using Chat GPT, and if they’re honest about it, maybe there’s no problem.

Maybe we should all be using it. Theoretically, I could ask Chat GPT to write this article. However, I think readers would notice. It wouldn’t sound natural.

Worse than that, it wouldn’t be healthy. If journalists, authors, opinion writers or whoever, start passing off this kind of writing as their own, people will stop reading. They also won’t know what’s real and what’s fake.

We used to believe that if someone makes a good argument on paper, then their argument holds some weight. But now it’s so easy to have the likes of Chat GPT create arguments, even the art and skill of debating is going to become redundant.

For example, I could ask Chat GPT to give me an argument in favour of Irish unity or to produce an article on that topic. At the same time, I could ask it to give me an article in favour of Ulster Unionism and it could do the job just as convincingly.

Since that’s the case, real writers might become redundant very soon. And everybody will be a good writer, including those with very dangerous opinions.

Of course, one positive feature of Chat GPT is that it’s useful for research. That’s what I use it for. It can also give a semi-impartial opinion about subjects. Recently I tried this out in a wee experiment. I had a conversation about Irish unity with Generative AI.

Anyone can do the same if they have a subscription. But since I’m arguing that we probably shouldn’t subscribe to such things, I’ll describe my wee chat without anyone else using GPT.

Basically, as is to be expected, Chat GPT believes Irish unity will happen at some stage. Recently, even Unionist heavyweights such as John Taylor (Baron Kilclooney) have suggested this is the direction of travel. Irish unification is probable at some point.

However, this doesn’t mean Chat GPT has joined some pan-nationalist front as the John Taylor of old might have claimed. It’s just interpreting data that’s publicly available. It absorbs information, sticks it together and gives you an answer to your question.

In the case of Irish unity, it does gather up some very good points. In the course of our conversation, it threw up things that neither side might want to hear. It told me that Republicans are often accused of talking into an echo chamber. Similarly, it accused Unionists of refusing to engage in debate and wanting to wish the whole thing away.

These, of course, aren’t Chat GPT’s thoughts. They’re just a scrapbook of other people’s thoughts put together into a response. The ideas have probably come from articles in this paper, The Belfast Telegraph, The Irish News, The Newsletter, the British Press etc. It probably even took some of its ideas from An Phoblacht, the republican news site.

And that again gives rise to a major problem with Chat GPT. When you use it to write articles, it’s not writing your words. It’s stealing other people’s. Working in a university, we tell this to students all the time. Chat GPT has no concept of plagiarism though it is designed in such a way that it rarely steals direct quotes. It paraphrases and summarises instead.

That still doesn’t make it right. It’s like the kid at school getting someone else to do their homework for them. Maybe they bully the smartest child in the class to write them an essay. Ah, at this point, you might be asking how does Chat GPT bully anyone?

Well, the answer is one that often surprises people. For a start Chat GPT and AI causes a lot of environmental damage. The servers use an incredible amount of water and energy. When you ask Chat GPT even a simple question it uses up way more energy than a Google search.

So when I had my conversation about Irish unity, I was using more than just the electricity running into my Macbook. According to the Medium website, “while a standard Google search is estimated to consume about 0.3 watt-hours (Wh) of electricity, a single ChatGPT prompt (using GPT-4) can consume around 3 to 5 Wh.”

But the use of energy isn’t the only concern. There’s a much bigger one for me and one that makes it weird asking Generative AI about its opinion on Irish unity. This is because people passionate about Irish unity often care about other causes such as that of Palestine.

Yet, tech giants are at the heart of the militarism that is destroying the Middle East right now. Google has a $1.2 billion contract providing AI and cloud services to the Israelis. And Open AI, parent company of Chat GPT, provides AI tools to the Pentagon for military purposes.

Facebook does the same. And Amazon. Microsoft too. Big tech is so deeply embedded in the military-industrial complex that it’s like fuel in the engine of a tank. When America and Israel murder their enemies at will, they do it off the back of our support for these companies.

And yet what are we to do? Quit Facebook or don’t order anything off Amazon? For most people that’s probably a step too far. But a nice start would be to at least accept that this is happening and maybe cut down on subscriptions.

That’s what I think I’m going to do with Chat GPT because of all that’s happening in the Middle East right now. And if I want to have conversations about Irish unity, it’s best to do that with people. Perhaps I should even follow Chat GPT’s closing piece of advice.

We should try having conversations with unionists and others; not just with ourselves or people who agree with us. And definitely not just with computers.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos