"Single-identity" fears for Caledon, should school close

4
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.
Close Icon

Find, save and share Public Notices that affect you in the area.

Search the Public Notice Portal What is the Public Notice Portal?

What is the Public Notice Portal?

The Public Notice Portal carries statutory public notices published in local newspapers and is the fastest and most effective way of finding out what is happening in YOUR neighbourhood.

Search the Public Notice Portal

An Education Authority proposal to close down St. Joseph’s PS, in Caledon, has met with strong opposition from Mid Ulster District Council and elected representatives alike, including Councillor Gael Gildernew who fears that closing the one Catholic school in the locality would turn Caledon into a “single identity” village.

Echoing some of the points made by the local authority in its response to the Education Authority, the Sinn Féin representative for Clogher Valley commented at last Thursday’s (March 26) monthly meeting of Mid Ulster District Council: “Caledon is a unique village [which] has been marginalised on the edge of this council area.

“There’s no clear alternative school community for the children attending St. Joseph’s to transfer to, and this closure will see the entire school community split across numerous schools in Counties Tyrone and Armagh, with the majority of available spaces in Middletown.

“This will also have an impact on the choice of secondary schools available to these children and to Mid Ulster District Council, and the district as a whole.

“These children won’t be guaranteed a secondary-school education in Mid Ulster, in schools such as Dungannon or Ballygawley, where they would naturally have gone, as Middletown Primary School is not a natural feeder to those schools.

“It’ll have an impact on them progressing on and then possibly taking up education opportunities, employment opportunities, and housing opportunities outside of Mid Ulster, when they naturally would have stayed in Mid Ulster — and this could be impactful to this council for generations to come.

“Caledon has planning permission for numerous housing developments. Approximately 50 houses are in the pipeline and it’s one of the local villages which still has capacity in the wastewater systems.

“Closing the school will potentially stop growth, and it will definitely have an impact on the Catholic community and potentially leave Caledon as a single-identity village — and this will be detrimental to us all.

“There have been decades spent on community and peacebuilding works and shared education programmes with Churchill Primary School, and that will all be lost.

“I believe there’s more to gain from the school being allowed to continue than there ever will be saved by closing it.

“The enrolment numbers have never been high in Caledon, and they may never reach the recommended threshold for a primary school.

“Mummy started me in St. Joseph’s when I was age three to try and keep the numbers up then, and I’m coming 50 on my next birthday.

“So, the numbers shouldn’t be the reason why this community loses a school. There are too many other factors at play.”

Echoing his party colleague’s view, Councillor Eugene McConnell (Clogher Valley DEA) said: “I just wanted to second my colleague’s proposal, but also to commend the campaign group that have rallied to save St. Joseph’s.

“I think it’s incumbent on all of us as councillors, right across every area, to do whatever we can to assist that campaign — because fundamentally, the lifeblood of any community is the primary school, it’s the school where it all starts out.

“It’s been a very dignified campaign to date, but the real success will be the endorsement and support from every political sector right across the communities — to rally behind them and do everything within their powers to save what is a vital rural commodity for the people of Caledon.

“I too would like to commend the response that has been pulled together and support it.”

Referring to a support rally held on March 21, Councillor Kevin McElvogue (Independent, Clogher Valley DEA) said he was pleased with the large attendance at the event: “I was at the protest last Saturday and there was a good crowd there — a really good crowd — and I hope it’ll change things.

“I hope the Department of Education will change their mind on this. But I propose that maybe the organising committee that was set up be brought in to meet the council.”

The proposal was seconded by Councillor Barry Monteith (Independent, Dungannon DEA).

He commented: “I was also at the protest march, and it was great to see people from all different backgrounds — a magnificent crowd, and all the young people there.

“The sad thing about this is that these are battles that rural communities shouldn’t have to be fighting.

“And sadly, the situation is that not all rural communities will win the battle. It would be far better if, rather than development proposals coming forward to close schools, there were development proposals coming forward as to how to reinvigorate schools, and how to build up schools.

“Rural communities are left high and dry, and they’re left having to do what urban communities don’t have to do — which is fight for basic services, and it’s just not acceptable.”

The Education Authority is proposing to close the rural school on August 31, 2027, or as soon as possible thereafter.

In their response, Mid Ulster Council officers wrote: “it is the opinion of the Council that there are number of flaws in relation to this proposal, specifically that the schools identified to take on the pupils from the St. Joseph’s catchment area are either already at capacity, or would involve travelling significant distances.

“There is also evidence of the potential for rising pupil enrolment numbers. This is as a result of over 50 mixed dwellings that have been granted planning approval across three housing developments in and around the village of Caledon.

“Council does not regard the closure of a primary school as a creative and innovative solution to the provision of sustainable education.

“Approximately 200 rural primary schools across Northern Ireland will have difficulty in meeting the Sustainable Schools Policy threshold requirement in order to be deemed sustainable, as they are more likely to have lower enrolments due to population dispersal.

“The Rural Needs Impact Assessment developed in 2025 in relation to the proposed 2026 closure stated that, ‘St Joseph’s PS is seen as a vital part of a shared future, working closely with Churchill PS and local Protestant communities. Its closure is feared to reverse decades of peacebuilding and integration’.

“This is a fear that has also been communicated to our elected members who have liaised with the leadership team of Churchill PS, who value their cross-community initiatives and feel strongly that the school be retained.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos