Find, save and share Public Notices that affect you in the area.
Search the Public Notice Portal What is the Public Notice Portal?What is the Public Notice Portal?
The Public Notice Portal carries statutory public notices published in local newspapers and is the fastest and most effective way of finding out what is happening in YOUR neighbourhood.
Search the Public Notice PortalA planning application, seeking permission to build a dwelling and domestic garage in the countryside, was deferred at the April 1 Mid Ulster Planning meeting, as the applicant has yet to convince planning officers that his plans would simply fill in a gap, and not constitute ribbon development.
The proposed location for the dwelling and garage is a plot of land adjacent to 65 Gortlenaghan Road, Cabragh.
The planning application was lodged by Bernard J. Donnelly Architectural Services, Ballygawley, on behalf of Sean McGuigan, 65 Gortlenaghan Road.
As things stand, what the applicant describes as a “gap” is deemed to be too big by Planning officers, and their current recommendation is to refuse the planning application.
Current policy dictates that a gap should only be big enough to accommodate up to two dwellings, and the proposed plot size, in the opinion of Planning officers, is just too big to meet that requirement.
Principal Planning Officer, Phelim Merrion commented at the planning meeting: “This application is for a dwelling in the countryside, and the application is put forward as a gap in a substantially and continuously built-up frontage.
“Members will be aware of the definition of a substantial and continuously built-up frontage — that there should be three buildings with a common frontage, and it must respect the development pattern in terms of size, scale, siting and plot size, and meet other planning and environmental considerations.
“In this case, there are three buildings to the south and one to the north, with a large engineering business set further back from the road to the north.
“The small building immediately to the north is not visible from the road and does not have a frontage to the road. It is set below the road and off a small lane.
“The gap proposed to fill here — between the dwelling to the south and the building to the north — is a fairly substantial gap, and it could accommodate more than two dwellings, taking account of the pattern of development here.
“The applicant was asked if they wished to provide a farming case, because there is a group of buildings to the south that are in their ownership, and that was not forthcoming.
“We also asked them to provide a biodiversity checklist because there is hedging to be removed, there is a watercourse to the rear of the site, and the site area itself is over 0.5 of a hectare.
“That is a requirement to provide a biodiversity checklist, and that was not submitted either.
“Because the proposal itself is for a large site between developments here that does not have a frontage to the north, it does not fulfil the requirements for a gap site within a substantial and continuously built-up frontage, and we do not have other information to allow us to consider impacts on the habitat.
“The application is therefore recommended for refusal this evening.”
The applicant’s representative was given an opportunity to address committee members, and he contended that the planning application did meet current policy.
He told committee members: “I accept what the planning officer was saying in relation to the biodiversity checklist, and I’ve asked the agent to submit that. That should be a fairly straightforward matter.
“In relation to the other issues, yes, the agent did say to me that there is potential for a farming justification for this. That is the group of buildings to the southwest of the site, and they have some additional land there as well.
“However, my position would be that this would meet the criteria under ribbon development infill. As Phelim said, there are three buildings to the south with two different entrances.
“And then you have the Water Service structure to the north, which is set in a sort of small triangular plot and does have an entrance out onto the road.
“So, I suppose, that is where the difference of opinion lies. From our perspective, the Water Service building has a curtilage and has an entrance, and therefore has frontage. It is not set behind another field.
“And then obviously we have the three buildings at the other end of the site in terms of the gap itself as well.
“You cannot accommodate more than two dwellings on the site. It is not physically possible to accommodate a third dwelling — there simply is not the room.
“So, from that perspective, we would be of the position that it does meet the criteria in terms of infilling of a substantial continuously built-up frontage.
“However, if members are still not convinced on that, we would ask for a deferral in terms of providing the outstanding information — both the biodiversity checklist and the farming case.”
While the senior Planning officer remained unconvinced that the frontage in question was small enough to constitute a gap, he deemed it fair to give the applicant an opportunity to argue otherwise, or to offer some farming justification for the proposed development.
He commented: “I think deferral is a reasonable option — if members are in agreement — not necessarily for a meeting on this one, but to advance the farming case.
“If you wish to do that, by all means. If you feel you can demonstrate it is a gap for no more than two dwellings, you can set that out as well.
“I am reasonably content that might offer — without prejudice of course — a better alternative here.”
Councillor Dan Kerr (Independent, Torrent DEA) concurred with the senior Planning officer that a deferral was justified in this case, and made that a proposal: “Just as the planning officer mentioned, perhaps we can defer it, and if the farming case will strengthen the applicant’s position, it should be explored further.”
Councillor Kerr’s proposal was seconded by Councillor Kevin McElvogue (Independent, Clogher Valley DEA), and the planning application will be duly revisited at a later stage.
Share