Denzil McDaniel: We are 'overwhelmed' by misinformation

Former US president Barack Obama speaking at Queen's University after he was awarded an honorary doctorate from Queen's University Belfast. <i>(Image: Queen's University Belfast/PA Wire)</i>
Former US president Barack Obama speaking at Queen's University after he was awarded an honorary doctorate from Queen's University Belfast. (Image: Queen's University Belfast/PA Wire)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Former U.S. President Barack Obama was in Belfast last week and among the topics he discussed was the importance of local journalism.

He warned of the dangers of polarisation fuelled by social media.

“If you flood the zone with nonsense, you don't have to convince people that this is true, you just have to make people doubt that anything is true,” said Obama in an interview with journalist Susan McKay.

Pilate asked in the Bible “what is truth?” and thousands of years later truth is proving more elusive than ever.

In addition to the unaccountable misinformation on social media, over years the “fake news” mantra by the power-hungry has deliberately and aggressively undermined trust in traditional media.

As it happens I was also at an event in Belfast last week, though it will hardly come as a shock to you that my visit attracted a little less attention than Obama’s.

But I did touch on the same theme when I spoke to the Public Interest News Foundation.

My former colleague, Trevor Birney and I opened their conference and spoke about the unhealthy nature of public discourse today, and how vital it is that journalism plays a responsible role in counteracting it.

I suggested that if the toxic nature of debate today had existed in the 1990s, we would never have achieved the historic Good Friday Agreement of 1998 which, whatever you think of it politically, saved so many lives.

The audience, mostly made up of small independent news organisations from Britain, seemed surprised.

I was actually surprised that they were surprised!

We all know how negative social media can be.

Many people have been abused personally by the keyboard warriors, some of it quite disgusting and intimidating.

Despite the changing landscape from the era when I worked there, many local newspapers still feel a responsibility to their communities and include positivity as well as covering the uncomfortable stuff.

I know many fine journalists in the locals and regionals and in broadcasting, and while nobody is claiming everyone is perfect, by and large our journalists are people of integrity performing an important role in society.

Meanwhile the big tech companies use algorithms to feed a lot of negativity which often encourages poisonous exchanges.

There is also an increasing level of misinformation being pushed out and we become overwhelmed.

It seems crazy that we now have more information than ever literally at our fingertips, but we just accept the bits we like.

It’s called confirmation bias.

In the context of events at Drumcree and the Garvaghy Road in recent weeks, one has to ask if social media age standards make for rational and calm debate.

Or assist those who would take us down a dangerous path?

If we feel our traditional media has a role to play in giving us balanced and fair coverage, there have been good and not-so-good on that score.

On the Nolan Live programme on BBC NI television last week, DUP leader Gavin Robinson was given a lot of air time and leeway to put his interpretation of the private briefing he’d received from the PSNI Chief Constable about the situation on the Garvaghy Road.

Aside from the fact that this advice would come before the courts a few days later, Robinson expounded the view that police intelligence meant that dissident republicans “might” have shot members of the Orange Order and police, that the Secretary of State had “bowed the knee” to threats of violence, disorder and terror.

Robinson referred to “rumours” that guns were available on the streets.

We should always take the threat of violence very seriously and this was serious stuff but I felt there was not enough pushback by Nolan and the whole balance of the show was not what we should expect from responsible BBC journalism.

Instead, Nolan moved on to the political implications for the DUP, and the tone was set for the keyboard warriors of social media to maintain the narrative for the next few days.

More of the security assessment emerged in court on Monday and Tuesday.

The PSNI intelligence assessment stated that dissident Republicans had attended the protest and possibly had ready access to firearms in the Garvaghy Road area, and said it was possible in the event of police removing protesters that firearms may be used to attack police.

It also said reliable intelligence indicated that mainstream Republicans were concerned about their ability to prevent disorder or control the dissident Republicans.

The assessment also said it was highly likely that increasing members of loyalists would attend the Portadown area and that disorder at Drumcree church remained a possibility with both sides converging on the area.

While everybody takes up their own stance on social media, what's clear is that there are still dangerous people on both sides who are prepared to take advantage and use violence.

I would contend that we knew that already, and indeed it was the very thing that many of us feared when the whole Drumcree controversy was re-opened again.

But the narrative over the past week branding residents and nationalists generally and indeed Orange Order members as somehow complicit in those “bad actors” prepared to use violence isn't just a misrepresentation, it is a dangerous one.

Unfortunately social media amplifies the hostility of negative voices.

Obama also said in Belfast, “Social media is built on algorithms. They are designed to hook you, which means they are going to reinforce your biases and prejudices.

“If you looked at why democracy is under attack, why everything is so polarised, if I had a blank pie chart and wanted to figure it out, a big piece would be people getting their news through social media.”

By the time the many responsible journalists here reported and analysed the court events, including the intelligence reports, those dialling up the rhetoric had already done their work.

All this at a time when cool, calm leadership is needed.

As I say, the atmosphere in 1998 in the Agreement negotiations was difficult enough.

Imagine if it been subject to the toxicity of social media.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos