Find, save and share Public Notices that affect you in the area.
Search the Public Notice Portal What is the Public Notice Portal?What is the Public Notice Portal?
The Public Notice Portal carries statutory public notices published in local newspapers and is the fastest and most effective way of finding out what is happening in YOUR neighbourhood.
Search the Public Notice PortalTwo planning applications are to be reconsidered after councillors raised concerns about whether the original decision-making process had given the applicant’s planning consultant his fair share of speaking rights.
An ad hoc council committee, held last Tuesday (November 10) agreed unanimously to refer the two applications, for the conversion of premises into bedsits and apartments, back to the Planning Committee.
The applications had been refused by the Planning Committee on 6 October, but the decision was subsequently subject to an admissible call-in.
Mr Kevin Quinn, Kilycanavan Road, Ardboe, had lodged a retrospective planning application for a change of use from a mechanics workshop to provide eight single-room bedsits in the vicinity of 52 Killycolpy Road, Ardboe.
Mr Quinn had also lodged a retrospective application to extend and make alterations to an existing dwelling and its adjoining unused shop floor to provide six self-contained apartments at 52 Killycolpy Road.
In correspondence to Planning officers, Mr Quinn outlined his issue as follows: “My concern is that permitting a further objector contribution without inviting my agent to answer it undermined the stated purpose of the normal speaking order.”
The ad hoc committee was tasked not with reconsidering the merits of the applications, but with examining whether the process used by the Planning Committee allowed proper and fair consideration of the relevant facts and issues.
Council Chief Executive, Adrian McCreesh told councillors in attendance at the November 10 meeting: “Members will be aware that I, as the chief executive, received an admissible call-in in relation to the decision of the Planning Committee.
“As an admissible call-in of a committee decision has been received, the Council is required to appoint an ad hoc committee of the Council to consider the process adopted by the decision-maker.
“The ad hoc committee’s role is to consider whether the process and procedure adopted at the Planning Committee of October 6 allowed for proper and fair consideration of the relevant facts and issues.
“The ad hoc committee may either refer the decision back to the Planning Committee, or support the decision taken by the Planning Committee.”
Councillor Quinn (SDLP, Torrent DEA) outlined his position as follows: “I just want to be clear from the outset that our decision to support this call-in was not about the merits of either planning application, nor was it an attempt to overturn the decisions by the Planning Committee.
“My concern was, and remains, ensuring the process followed was fair, transparent and beyond reasonable criticism. Having considered the concerns raised, I felt that there were legitimate questions about how speaking rights were exercised at the Planning Committee on October 6.
“Our Planning Committee protocol sets out the normal speaking order, with objectors speaking before applicants, specifically to allow applicants the opportunity to respond to issues raised. Now, I fully recognise the discretion afforded to the Chair in managing those proceedings.
“However, where one party is given an additional opportunity to speak after the other has made their contribution, I believe it is reasonable to examine whether both parties were afforded a fair opportunity to respond. This is particularly relevant when one party was physically present at the meeting and the other was participating remotely.
“I am not suggesting that any procedural failing has been established. That is precisely why we have this process: to examine concerns, consider the evidence and determine whether there is an issue that needs to be addressed.
“I believe the video recording of the meeting should be considered alongside the published minutes to establish exactly what happened and whether both parties were given a fair opportunity to be heard.
“There’s also a wider responsibility on us as elected representatives. Planning decisions can have significant consequences and, where concerns about the process are raised, there is always the potential for costly legal challenges. I would much rather see this Council use its own established procedures to examine and, where necessary, address those concerns than have matters unnecessarily escalated towards judicial review.
“That is not to suggest that every applicant who disagrees with a planning decision should have the decision called in. But where a specific and credible concern about procedural fairness has been raised, I believe we have a responsibility to take it seriously.
“Ultimately, I supported this call-in because I believe we have a responsibility to protect both the integrity of our planning process and the Council itself.
“If, having considered the evidence, this committee concludes that there was a material procedural failing, then referring the matter back to the Planning Committee for reconsideration would be the responsible course of action.”
Councillor Karol McQuade (Dungannon DEA) concurred with his SDLP colleague, commenting: “I’d just like to back Councillor Quinn there. I would recommend that both applications be returned to the Planning Committee. I think everything that Malachy said there is relevant to the Council.”
Councillor Dan Kerr (Independent, Torrent DEA) expressed a similar sentiment, commenting: “Just to echo the comments of Councillor Quinn, just for good governance. That’s my concern, and I think the right decision is to maybe refer back to the Planning Committee.”
Councillor Córa Corry (Sinn Féin, Carntogher DEA) formally proposed referring the two planning applications to the Planning Committee: “Just in light of what we’ve heard tonight and from the papers, I think probably the best thing to do is to refer back to the Planning Committee, as they are the ones that have the training and expertise in Planning matters.”
Councillor Corry’s proposal was seconded by Councillor Wesley Brown (DUP, Magherafelt DEA).
With consensus reached on this option, the planning applications will return to the Planning Committee for reconsideration.
Share