Politicians dislike delivering bad news. So when Minister for Infrastructure John O’Dowd travelled to Enniskillen to launch the All-Island Rail Strategy in July, it is hard to know whether his motivation was bravado, foolishness or a bit of both.
For whilst the rest of the island was digesting the news that it could receive €30bn of rail investment in the decades ahead, the message for Fermanagh was much less palatable.
In their wisdom, Stormont and its consultants had declared that only one of the 32 counties on this island is unworthy of having rail – and it was John O’Dowd’s task that summer’s day to tell Fermanagh that it would have the honour of becoming the worst-connected county in the United Kingdom or Ireland.
There are currently five counties without rail on this island – Fermanagh, Tyrone, Donegal, Cavan and Monaghan.
All are in Ulster, all located along the Border, and together they leave a gaping hole in the island’s rail network.
The All-Ireland Rail Review was an ideal opportunity to address that, and it did indeed acknowledge that rail provision in the northwest is poor.
Two public consultations were held during the Strategy’s development (2021 and 2023), and it was a surprise to many when the greatest source of input to those came from the Fermanagh-Omagh District – Northern Ireland’s smallest council.
It was the source of 1,100 submissions to the first consultation (16 per cent of the total).
Indeed, the top four council areas for submissions were all in the northwest of the island (Fermanagh-Omagh, Derry-Strabane, Donegal and Mid-Ulster), accounting for half of the contributions received.
In 2023, a draft version of the Rail Strategy was published, revealing for the first time that Fermanagh could be the only county left without rail.
A second public consultation followed – with Fermanagh again the largest source of contributions (30 per cent of the total), plus a third of all responses objecting to Fermanagh’s exclusion.
Despite being a small county, and despite rail being a folk memory for most people here, this level of public engagement illustrates the passion that exists within Fermanagh to see rail return.
It was therefore galling that all those voices were ignored when the final Rail Strategy was published in July.
As a result, future rail maps of Ireland will not only confirm the suspicion that Fermanagh is ‘the forgotten county’, but will upgrade that status to one of abandonment.
The All-Island Strategy put a £330m price tag on the restoration of rail between Omagh and Enniskillen, which it rejected as too costly.
Yet the same strategy also recommended a new link between Portadown and Mullingar, via Cavan and Monaghan.
This unexpected proposal was pitched as a way to connect Belfast with Galway – a route which the Strategy acknowledged would have low demand.
Suspicion therefore abounds that political pressure may have been applied to ensure Cavan and Monaghan would see their rail restored, whilst there was no-one advocating similarly for Fermanagh.
It should be noted that the distance between Portadown and Mullingar is over three times longer than Enniskillen-Omagh; that Enniskillen has a much larger population than any town in Monaghan or Cavan; and that passenger demand between Enniskillen and Belfast would likely exceed that between Belfast and Mullingar or Galway.
How could it therefore be economically viable to open a rail line between Portadown and Mullingar (welcome though it would be), but not between Enniskillen and Omagh?
At the same time that the Minister was in Enniskillen declaring he had neither cash nor desire to return rail to Fermanagh, his Department was shovelling a further £45m towards the new Grand Central Station in Belfast.
It is a vast £340m+ transport hub designed to accommodate 20 million passengers a year – a figure it seems unlikely to ever reach during its lifespan.
The Great Victoria Street rail and Europa bus stations which it replaced were both less than 30 years old, in perfectly usable condition, and better than most transport facilities elsewhere in Northern Ireland.
Replacing them was therefore a question of choice rather than necessity – especially at such a hefty price tag.
And particularly when you consider that Belfast city has 10 other rail stations anyway – more per-capita than any comparable city.
Did so much money really need to be spent on a single transport hub in Belfast, when a lower sum would have reconnected Fermanagh to the rail network for centuries to come?
Stormont’s refusal to restore rail to Enniskillen will carry a price – to be paid by the people of a county that will be less accessible and therefore less attractive to businesses, tourists and residents alike.
We are told that there aren’t enough people in Fermanagh to warrant rail.
Yet infrastructure doesn’t just respond to population density – it also helps drive it.
Common sense dictates that people and businesses are more likely to gravitate towards areas where infrastructure is good, in preference to those where it’s poor.
So, making Fermanagh less accessible than everywhere else will undoubtedly make it poorer and less populous – which in future years will be used to continue denying it rail.
Cause and effect, combining in a circle of negative reinforcement.
It speaks volumes as to where Fermanagh sits within Stormont’s priorities that a non-essential transport hub in a city well-served by rail was deemed of greater importance than ensuring that every county in Northern Ireland gets the basic level of infrastructure needed to help meet its potential.
The truth is that Fermanagh is just not a priority for those who run Stormont – whether politicians or civil servants.
Because if it was, the recommendation to leave it so uniquely disconnected would never have been published.
When John O’Dowd stood by Enniskillen Castle in July, he described his decision to make Fermanagh a no-go zone for rail as “a chapter in the book, not the end of the story”, with a promise to review the situation again in 10 years, by when we all know it will be the same old story again, just on a different day.
The good news is that the All-Island Rail Strategy is merely a set of government-endorsed recommendations – that politicians can choose to implement or ignore.
Just over two years from now, 2027 will mark the 70th anniversary of Fermanagh losing its rail.
It will also see the next Stormont and council elections held here.
We need every voice in Fermanagh united between now and those elections to demand the political change of heart required for Enniskillen to be added to the All-Island Rail Strategy.
The alternative is to accept a Fermanagh which is isolated, disconnected, and increasingly irrelevant to this island’s future.
Steve Bradley is Chair of ‘Into The West’ – the rail campaign for Fermanagh, Tyrone, Derry and Donegal.
Share