Tom Elliott: We may differ on Legacy issues but should expect fairness

File photo of the aftermath of the Omagh Bomb in 1998. <i>(Image: PA Wire.)</i>
File photo of the aftermath of the Omagh Bomb in 1998. (Image: PA Wire.)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

One thing that we are certain of in Northern Ireland is that there will not be agreement on Legacy issues; there will be very differing opinions of the past.

One aspect of Legacy that there can be no quarrel about is the facts.

These facts are that 90 per cent of the killings that took place during what is known as ‘The Troubles’ in Northern Ireland were caused by terrorists.

Approximately 60 per cent of those murders were by Republican terrorists; 30 per cent by Loyalist terrorists, and 10 per cent by others, including security forces.

On this matter, there is a clear imbalance with the investigations, reviews and enquiries into Legacy killings, with the vast majority of such reconsiderations looking into actions of security forces and not into terrorists.

At a previous Northern Ireland Select Committee, former Lord Chief Justice, Sir Declan Morgan, stated that it seems to him that trust and confidence have been lost as a result of the disparity between the opportunities of those whose relatives have been killed, or those who have been injured as a result of state activity, and those many hundreds or thousands of people who have lost their lives as a result of terrorist activity.

Last week, we heard the Coroner's verdict on the IRA terrorists who were in possession of a heavy machine gun and probably more weapons of destruction.

This has angered and enraged many people in our community, particularly innocent victims.

These were four people who were in an IRA terrorist unit, who were obviously intent on causing mayhem, destruction, and – if possible – murder.

They had just launched an attack with a heavy machine gun and probably other weapons on a police station.

It is interesting that the Coroner goes into some detail about the deaths of the four IRA terrorists, but makes less comment on the actions of those terrorists in both the immediate and more distant past.

He does mention that they had welded an improvised metal pipe to the top and centre of the rear tailgate of a lorry that had been hijacked and attached a heavy Russian-made DShK machine gun to it and drove it to Coalisland RUC Station at around 22:40 hours, where some 60 rounds were fired.

I didn’t notice anywhere in the Coroner’s findings any comments to indicate that the actions of the IRA members, in launching an attack on Coalisland Police Station, were not justified, or the context of the situation that the soldiers were operating in.

Given the significant commentary surrounding the incidents, many would have thought that commentary would have been made about those actions that clearly attempted to cause destruction and murder at the police station.

These were not criminals who had broken into a shop or got into a fight.

These were hardened criminal terrorists intent on murder and destruction.

In answer to recent questions submitted by my colleague, Lord Empey, we are informed that in the past five years, £4,682,122 of compensation has been paid to “relatives of those shot and killed by soldiers in Northern Ireland during The Troubles”.

That cohort included 20 individual claims.

We are further informed that there are another 107 live claims of a similar nature against the MOD.

I assume that no such financial compensation has been paid to members of terrorist atrocities such as the Enniskillen Poppy Day Bomb, the Teebane Massacre, the La Mon Hotel bomb victims, or thousands of other innocent victims.

This is another glaring injustice outworking of The Troubles in Northern Ireland and beyond.

We are conscious of the recent calls about the lack of input and cooperation from the Republic of Ireland authorities, with little or no provision of information on many of the brutal murders that took place by Republican terrorists in Northern Ireland.

I recall that when Sir Declan Morgan and former Director of Public Prosecutions Barra McGrory were giving evidence at the Northern Ireland Affairs Select Committee in Westminster three years ago, there were indications that there should be an equal approach between Northern Ireland and the Republic, and that the latter needs to take a look at its Article 2 obligations in the past.

More recently, one of the Omagh Bomb victims said she believes the Irish authorities may have had advance knowledge of the bombing, and failed to pass it on.

In her view, this may explain their reticence to hold their own public inquiry – as urged in the Belfast High Court.

Then we have former Republic of Ireland Foreign Affairs Minister Charlie Flanagan, who said that the Republic of Ireland should have established its own parallel Omagh inquiry.

Although during previous talks processes when challenged to provide information for the Kingsmill families, there was little response from Mr. Flanagan and the Republic of Ireland government.

The Republic’s government are quick to call on the United Kingdom to provide information and support victims, but when it comes to the Irish fulfilling any level of equivalence or delivery for victims in Northern Ireland, they fall far short.

We now have a review of Legacy issues by the new Labour Government.

The missing link in much of this review of the past is the glaring omission of meaningful cooperation by the Irish government.

Despite the many public pronouncements from Dublin promising full disclosure by the Irish State, the reality is that they are missing in action when it comes to providing meaningful information on the numerous plots and murders, plus allegations of collusion with terrorists, that took place from their territory.

In a further recent development, there is more bad news for the Police Ombudsman with the court finding that she had exceeded her powers.

This is yet another successful legal challenge by the Northern Ireland Retired Police Officers Association against sweeping commentary within the Police Ombudsman’s reports.

I note the Police Ombudsman has indicated she will appeal this decision, which creates further financial demands on the public purse when such money could be used for health, education or other public service.

As I said at the beginning of this article, dealing with the past is something we are unlikely to get agreement on; however, what we should have is fairness and equity.

Lord Elliott of Ballinamallard is a former Ulster Unionist MLA, MP for Fermanagh and South Tyrone and leader of the party.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos