Tom Elliott on making better trade arrangements with the EU or the US

Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds, who is expected to raise the interests of Britain's steel industry and other concerns in talks on a potential economic deal with US President Donald Trump as he visits Washington DC. Photo: PA Wire.
Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds, who is expected to raise the interests of Britain's steel industry and other concerns in talks on a potential economic deal with US President Donald Trump as he visits Washington DC. Photo: PA Wire.
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

We thought times were interesting in the run-up to Brexit, but they are likely to get even more interesting for United Kingdom/EU relations following the election of President Donald Trump over in the US.

Brexit was an extremely controversial debate, and the outworkings since Brexit have been equally controversial, significantly impacting Northern Ireland businesses.

For instance, many businesses in Northern Ireland have faced increased costs and delays due to customs and regulatory checks introduced by the Northern Ireland Protocol.

The agriculture sector, in particular, has been hit hard, with fears of potential trade barriers affecting exports and imports.

It appears to me that the EU has taken an extremely aggressive stance against any future relationship with the United Kingdom.

The previous United Kingdom government didn’t seem interested in any attempt to improve the relationship, and Northern Ireland was front and centre of these relationship difficulties with the EU, with the ‘Irish Sea Border’ and the problems it brought.

With the Labour Party coming to power, it was obvious there was a softening of the Government’s approach to the EU, in anticipation of having a closer relationship with our European neighbours.

I don’t believe there is any intention of bringing the United Kingdom back into the European Union; however, a deal could be forthcoming that sees the United Kingdom having a much closer working relationship on many issues such as security, trade deals, and regulations.

Such a deal could end the Northern Ireland problem of the Irish Sea Border, as all of the United Kingdom would be in the same position with the EU.

Just a short time into Trump’s tenure, all of those potential improved relationships may be fading away.

Now, with the introduction of the new United States of America President and his proposals, these plans seem to be quickly outdated.

Of course, all is not rosy in the EU garden either.

They are struggling to have all the member states on the same page in relation to the Russia-Ukraine war, and some of their countries – including the Republic of Ireland – have an extremely small or almost nil defence budget, which has an overall impact on the defences of the EU.

In theory, recent events should make it easier to strike an agreement on closer relationships, including security cooperation and trade deals.

The often-loose arrangements on defence issues may not be a good long-term prospect, particularly given the potential for longer-term conflicts.

The EU is in a weaker position if they don’t have a more positive security and defence arrangement with the United Kingdom.

Then, of course, we add the complication of the election of Donald Trump, who has announced significant trade tariffs on many close trading partners.

He has suggested significant goods tariffs on the EU, but potentially less so on the United Kingdom.

If the United Kingdom can potentially get a better deal with the USA on tariffs than if they were part of, or indeed close to, the EU, will that be potentially off-putting for the United Kingdom to be part of any closer arrangement with the EU?

With all this in the mix, there are various competing issues. With so much time and attention being devoted to the Russian-Ukraine war, the EU attempting to improve European armed forces and defence mechanisms, and the considerations as to how to deal with Donald Trump’s interventions, any forthcoming United Kingdom/EU summit might not achieve as much as was hoped for at the latter part of last year.

To some, this may all seem far removed from the interests of Fermanagh and Tyrone – but not so.

The world is a much smaller place now in terms of communication, trade, security, and the knock-on impact of issues that are 4,000 miles away.

Most are very aware of the negative impact the Protocol and Windsor Framework have had on businesses and individuals importing goods from Great Britain.

The next moves of the United Kingdom government are vital to ensuring a positive economic future for this part of the country.

If the EU continues to make any relationships with the United Kingdom difficult and the USA is more favourable to trade arrangements with the United Kingdom than the EU, we could find ourselves in Northern Ireland being in the middle of a trade war, with high American tariffs on EU goods – including those from the Republic of Ireland.

Due to us being part of the EU economic base, some of our goods could be subject to those high tariffs.

On the opposite side of that, if the United Kingdom engages in a closer relationship with the EU, which may benefit Northern Ireland by the removal of the Irish Sea Border, Trump could then impose higher tariffs on the United Kingdom as a whole, similar to those imposed on the EU, affecting everyone in the Republic of Ireland, Northern Ireland, or Great Britain.

The next moves by the United Kingdom government will be crucial in terms of the future of trading, defence, and the economy for all of us.

The experience of past negotiations by the UK, particularly over Brexit, the Protocol, and the Windsor Framework, has not resulted in a good outcome for many businesses and individuals in this community.

The United Kingdom government has a much stronger hand to play in negotiations with both the EU and USA than I believe they think, but if they seem weak to those they are negotiating with, they will be exploited and outplayed.

They should not allow that to happen.

The art of negotiation by the United Kingdom has been lost for years prior to Brexit, simply due to the fact that they didn’t have to negotiate at the same level on the world stage, as most such deliberations were done directly by the EU, which again left the United Kingdom on the back foot.

They need to take the lead in the current uneasy situation and do what is best for the people, realising that to do the best for your own people, you sometimes have to ensure that some wider world issues are vital, and must be dealt with.

If the United Kingdom government mess up any upcoming deliberations, it will have potential long-term negative impacts for the people of Fermanagh and Tyrone.

They must not allow that to happen.

Lord Elliott of Ballinamallard is a former Ulster Unionist MLA, MP for Fermanagh and South Tyrone and leader of the party.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos